Jedi vs Sith - Star Wars RPG

[Enigma]

Jedi vs Sith

We are a Star Wars RPG/collaborative fiction forum.

Link: jedivsith.boards.net

I would appreciate any and all feedback, as I'm getting ready to do some new advertising for the forum. Getting a few fresh pairs of eyes to look at our forum will be invaluable.

Thanks!


Administrative notes:
- I am the Co-Admin: jedivsith.boards.net/user/5
- I believe our founding Admin created the skin (which I have modified) but I don't know for sure. If it's yours, let me know and I'll be happy to credit you.

[Enigma]

bump

[Enigma]

bump

[Jareth]

really nice keep up

[URBAN]

Hello there Enigma

FIRST IMPRESSIONS:
Your site is very well laid out, its neat and orginized. The colors you chose work well together and everything is legeble and pleasant to the eye. Its a nice site. However:

I think that your site would look a lot better if i t had a visual banner as opposed to just the site name. Especially being a star wars site. I feel that some pretty cool things could be done for a banner for this site (if you need, I can recommend some resource sites where you can request a banner).

I also think that you should get rid of the old/new folders on your boards, or at least you should replace the folders with images that go with your site (maybe lightsabors, or droids, even blue circles would be better).

Other than that the layout is great, you did a fine job.

LOOKING DEEPER:
The only thing I can comment about here is the everything looks good, its all well written and well orginized. No one should have trouble finding anything.

Normally I would review the site setting and or plot, but my knowledge of star wars is limited so I'll leave that for someone else XD

ALL IN ALL:
Its a nice site!
7.5 / 10

[Enigma]

URBAN: Thank you for your input!

Replacing the folder icons is already on my to-do list, so I'm glad to have some confirmation on that idea being a good one.

The banner you see now is already an improvement from where we started, but I appreciate a fresh opinion. I'll explore some options there. Thanks again!

[URBAN]

Feb 27, 2015 22:15:38 GMT -8 Enigma said:

URBAN: Thank you for your input!

Replacing the folder icons is already on my to-do list, so I'm glad to have some confirmation on that idea being a good one.

The banner you see now is already an improvement from where we started, but I appreciate a fresh opinion. I'll explore some options there. Thanks again!

No problem Enigma ,
Always happy to help lol

[Tumbleweed]

Feb 24, 2015 7:05:49 GMT -8 Jareth said:

really nice keep up

Hi there,

Please read the rules regarding critiquing a forum and you may want to read what we consider spam posts:

Rules: support.proboards.com/thread/3605/goayb-rules-read-before-post

Spam: support.proboards.com/thread/3122

Thanks.

[Enigma]

bump

[Enigma]

bump

[Enigma]

bump

[nariadreaming]

I really like it. As others have said it's easy to navigate, it's very well laid out, and it's visually appealing. I grew up on a similar forum for Star Wars Nuts, so for me, it was a very nice trip down memory lane.

I agree that replacing the folder icons with something in-world would be a great touch.

I noticed you're going through a bit of a RP-restructuring. It's really neat to see the input you're seeking from your active members in shaping the future of the forums.

Well done!

[Enigma]

bump

[Enigma]

bump

[Enigma]

bump