GT Mafia: Round 2 ((Post-Game))

[Phaelyn]

I'm still not totally convinced as to who's guilty and innocent yet. I am not putting in an official vote at the moment, but I'm really leaning towards Ricky here.

I think I believe Ryan is the detective. He's seemed trustworthy for this entire game round, and I've kind of believed him from the beginning...I feel like listening to him would be a good thing right now. Ricky's been my top suspect for a while now, and Lost as well...

Know what? I'll just vote now. I am voting Ricky.

[Pats Freak 101]

Jan 1, 2011 16:43:56 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Jan 1, 2011 16:39:02 GMT -8 Pats Freak 101 said:

I'm not sure I trust ryan. If I had my back against the wall I would try the same.

Syko was a best guess. It could have happened to anyone. You were also the first person to support me yesterday.

I finally discovered a mafia, Ricky. Trust me for 1 more day. I'm dead tonight anyway. We can't stop the mafia from killing me.

Even if you don't believe that, everyone can kill me first thing tomorrow if I'm lying. I will say now. If Ricky is a villager I will throw myself off a cliff first thing tomorrow morning (and be the death for day 4).

I am the detective, Ricky is mafia. I will die tonight anyway since I can't be saved.

I'll wait to vote, but I will probably side with you again. You can't blame a potential body for being suspicious.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

I know I just posted my request that we wait at least until Ryan gets back online before voting up a majority, but there are 6 votes for Ricky already. I want to hear Ryan's answer before the night phase if he is really in danger of being killed tonight.

Once he responds I'm going to vote for ricky, but as of now I choose not to vote

See below.

[Ryan Roos]

Jan 1, 2011 16:53:39 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Funny, I just gave a speech saying how you shouldn't be our number one suspect, and then you throw this out? You do realize that if you are lying about Ricky you probably shortened your lifespan. If you are the detective and honestly think you are going to die tonight, which other 2 did you investigate then?

As for votes, I would like to request we refrain from allowing a majority to be reached until I at least get a response please (That would be 9, right?).

I realize I'm actually dead tonight. I would like to refrain from revealing the two unless they give me permission.

Obviously the mafia know who all the villagers are but they don't know where our alliances are. I'd prefer not to give them that information.

Ricky is mafia. Believe me or not.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Jan 1, 2011 17:01:23 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Jan 1, 2011 16:53:39 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Funny, I just gave a speech saying how you shouldn't be our number one suspect, and then you throw this out? You do realize that if you are lying about Ricky you probably shortened your lifespan. If you are the detective and honestly think you are going to die tonight, which other 2 did you investigate then?

As for votes, I would like to request we refrain from allowing a majority to be reached until I at least get a response please (That would be 9, right?).

I realize I'm actually dead tonight. I would like to refrain from revealing the two unless they give me permission.

Obviously the mafia know who all the villagers are but they don't know where our alliances are. I'd prefer not to give them that information.

Ricky is mafia. Believe me or not.

Very well I believe you. I will refrain from voting for now, but will change my vote within the hour if nothing changes.

[bagheera]

Jan 1, 2011 16:35:53 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Jan 1, 2011 16:34:35 GMT -8 Dove said:

I was nurse last game, and I saved someone two nights in a row, Ryan, dear. If they are legit, and choose you again tonight, you are safe.

Bagheera confirm rule for double save or not publicly please.

Can the doctor save the same person 2 nights in a row?

I wasn't sure what Aether had done last game, so I consulted what was the starting idea for the game here and went with what is apparently the common rule, no saving the same person back-to-back.

---

Okay, got the votes so far tallied.

VOTES
Ryan: Ricky
Dove: Ricky
Jetta: Ricky
Crow: Ricky
Phaelyn: Ricky

[VS Admin]

Here's what it comes down to. If Ryan is lying, he dies tomorrow.

I vote Ricky

If Ryan is right, I hope he has a will written out showing the names of the trustworthy villagers.

[Ryan Roos]

I'm waiting for Ricky and the mafia contingent to post a counter movement.

Or maybe they know they've been found out and are going to stay hidden as best they can.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Ok, I will submit my vote for Ricky now. I'm convinced. And I hope Ryan makes it through the night either way. In addition, I did not think it through before requesting Ryan to disclose the others he investigated. Revealing those names would put those villagers in danger by the mafia. Ryan now appears to be acting with the best interests of the village and the villagers in mind, so I trust him.

[CheatAreZee]

I guess it's a good thing I decided to check on the thread before heading out for the night

Looks like everyone has their mind made up already, but I'd hate to let everyone know Ryan is just making another educated guess like the last round, only I don't want to give in like syko did to let another villager go down. I am not mafia, and I really don't understand how Ryan can be trusted after what's gone down the last couple of days. But if you really want to follow with his 'guidance' again for another round, then so be it. I'm afraid you'll be quite disappointed when you find out that yet another villager has gone down, however. I think it was pretty clear after the last round that Ryan would be the top suspect to all of us since he mislead everyone to vote against syko, so he already knew he was a sinking ship either way. He's just trying to take one last villager down with him and currently you're all falling for it yet again.

With these events, my obvious vote right now is for Ryan. I hope others will come to there senses, but it's understandable if you don't side on me with this one; I'm not as good with words as he is to tangle your minds. You will be disappointed though if you stick with your votes to go against me.

[VS Admin]

Ricky-

With the Syko vote he posted what evidence he had that made him think Syko was mafia. He never claimed for certain that Syko was mafia. Everyone voted with him because it was the best evidence anyone had.

Now that he is solidly claiming you are mafia, we will know very shortly if Ryan is a liar. You acted suspicious at the office, and with his claim of being the detective and having found you out I am solidly behind Ryan until he is proven wrong.

[Ryan Roos]

There's Ricky! ;D

Okay you other 3 can come out now. Please vote with Ricky against me. A nice round number of 4 votes for Ryan would be great in my chart.

Voting Ricky (8)

Voting Ryan (1)

[/td][td]No Votes (7)[/td]
[/tr]

[tr]
[td]Ryan Roos
Dove
Jetta
Crow
Phaelyn
Patrick Clinger
Dom
Blizz[/td]
[td]Ricky Zyvoloski[/td]
[/td][td]**hp
Alex Zechiel
Lost
Pats Freak 101
Shiraz
woop
ZAR[/td]
[/tr]
[/table]

[B L I Z Z]

I'm voting for Ricky. He seems to be the odd man out and the odds are stacked against him. Sorry to say, he must be let go.

[Alex Zechiel]

Ricky, but on the condition that if Ryan's not dead by tomorrow, we lynch him.

[Pats Freak 101]

So long, Ricky