ProBoards Mafia Game 4 (POST-GAME)

[aether]

I'll vote for Andrea.

I have no reason, to be honest, but I feel bad about skimming pretty much every post in this thread so far.

[★Fuzzy★]

I'll go with ryan on this one and vote andrea.

[The Dancing Lock Guy]

I'll vote Andrea as well, 'mrrca.

[Syko Nachoman]

Andrea.

*drinks liquefied sandwich*

[Ryan Roos]

Rooschach's Journal
Day 2 of new life

Had lunch on main street.
Watched villagers walking
by. Talked to the town
doctor. Doctor says I am
fully recovered from coma.

I told the doctor I thought
Andrea was suspicious. The
doctor disagrees. We talked
for hours. We reviewed all
possibilities. I am left
with a list of villagers
and a list of mafia. The mafia
list is too big.

I decide to start with people
I haven't seen on the mafia
list. Maybe they are hiding.

One person rises to the top
in this way. And he tried
to kill me in my coma. The he
disappeared after the
murders really started.

I change my vote to icraft.

I decide to watch Andrea carefully.
If she slips up, she dies.

[Syko Nachoman]

Jan 30, 2011 13:31:11 GMT -8 Syko Nachoman said:

Andrea.

*drinks liquefied sandwich*

Withdrawn.

[Trill]

*puts this back on my Recent Topics*
And, um, who did you all kill when I voted for bagheera? *cough*

[aether]

Jan 30, 2011 11:55:35 GMT -8 aether said:

I'll vote for Andrea.

I have no reason, to be honest, but I feel bad about skimming pretty much every post in this thread so far.

I'll withdraw my vote as well.

[Phaelyn]

2 Andrea - Fuzzy, DLG
1 iCraft - Ryan Roos

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Hmm...Andrea or iCraft? What's the evidence against iCraft anyway? You mentioned him trying to kill you while you were in your coma, how is that even possible? The whole scenario right now just seems weird

I'll vote iCraft but I would like to hear more evidence too

You know what, they both look suspicious. I want to hear more evidence before submitting my vote. This is getting difficult now

[Pepper]

dom: I think Ryan is referring to iCraft voting for him on the first day.

But if we're going to use that as evidence, shouldn't we also be looking at people like Thomas K who was the first to bring up that Ryan could be a mafia member in a coma? I agree that the disappearing is pretty suspicious, but I can't be satisfied for voting for iCraft based on those reasons alone when so many others voted for Ryan, or thought about it, when he was in a coma, too.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Jan 30, 2011 15:23:25 GMT -8 Pepper said:

dom: I think Ryan is referring to iCraft voting for him on the first day.

But if we're going to use that as evidence, shouldn't we also be looking at people like Thomas K who was the first to bring up that Ryan could be a mafia member in a coma? I agree that the disappearing is pretty suspicious, but I can't be satisfied for voting for iCraft based on those reasons alone when so many others voted for Ryan, or thought about it, when he was in a coma, too.

I don't know...We all thought the mafia could put their own in a coma before phaelyn said they weren't allowed to, I was thinking it too at one point but thought it was kinda weird...I think there are beginning to be too many rules now, I yearn for simpler times

I'll vote in a bit, I want to see if Ryan has further evidence, I am leaning towards iCraft or Andrea at this point

[Pepper]

Jan 30, 2011 15:32:56 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Jan 30, 2011 15:23:25 GMT -8 Pepper said:

dom: I think Ryan is referring to iCraft voting for him on the first day.

But if we're going to use that as evidence, shouldn't we also be looking at people like Thomas K who was the first to bring up that Ryan could be a mafia member in a coma? I agree that the disappearing is pretty suspicious, but I can't be satisfied for voting for iCraft based on those reasons alone when so many others voted for Ryan, or thought about it, when he was in a coma, too.

I don't know...We all thought the mafia could put their own in a coma before phaelyn said they weren't allowed to, I was thinking it too at one point but thought it was kinda weird...I think there are beginning to be too many rules now, I yearn for simpler times

True. I guess my point is that if we're going to look at iCraft for trying to vote for Ryan we should be looking at everyone who voted for Ryan. And if I omit that evidence based on that reasoning, the only thing against iCraft is the fact that they've disappeared, and I wouldn't want to lynch them on that alone.

I'm the same as you on the voting thing, too. I don't want to do another blind lynch again. =\

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Yeah, look how those have turned out so far. We've taken out nobody but our allies, some of them very important to us winning in our struggles against the mafia We need to get this next one right.

On a side note, was iCraft around at all last night? Phaelyn said she was waiting on someone, and if bagheera was the godfather and she got the mafia vote in, and the doctor saved Syko, then that leaves the Mafia's double agent as the only remaining special role that is required for sunrise. Whoever the double agent is was the one holding up the game. It makes sense when you think about it.

[Pepper]

iCraft's last post in the Mafia thread was to vote for Trill... and she only had one post at all yesterday, at night.