Who's The Boss: Game 2 [GAME OVER]

[Pepper]

I have a question. How does Syko saying he has 24 ribs answer whether he is male or female? XD 'Cause that definitely screwed us over.

[Mr. Spartan]

Mar 7, 2011 8:50:15 GMT -8 Pepper said:

I have a question. How does Syko saying he has 24 ribs answer whether he is male or female? XD 'Cause that definitely screwed us over.

his reasoning was that he had 24 ribs. all male and female humans have this amount. so he answered the question in a way he didn't have to tell what gender he was. he answered it truthfully, since men do have 24 ribs.

[Sir Neless]

sneaky

[Phaelyn]

Mar 7, 2011 8:58:46 GMT -8 Mr. Spartan said:

Mar 7, 2011 8:50:15 GMT -8 Pepper said:

I have a question. How does Syko saying he has 24 ribs answer whether he is male or female? XD 'Cause that definitely screwed us over.

his reasoning was that he had 24 ribs. all male and female humans have this amount. so he answered the question in a way he didn't have to tell what gender he was. he answered it truthfully, since men do have 24 ribs.

That's pretty unfair, though. That would be like me being asked the same question and saying "I have two legs" or "I don't like wearing socks". Sure, I'm answering the question truthfully, but it's really on the verge of cheating.

[Sir Neless]

I don't know why but saying I don't wear socks a male comes to mind with that lol

[Phaelyn]

Mar 7, 2011 9:22:48 GMT -8 Sir Neless said:

I don't know why but saying I don't wear socks a male comes to mind with that lol

I don't wear socks.

[Mr. Spartan]

Mar 7, 2011 9:26:13 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Mar 7, 2011 9:22:48 GMT -8 Sir Neless said:

I don't know why but saying I don't wear socks a male comes to mind with that lol

I don't wear socks.

i only wear them when i run. i have a friend that doesn't wear them at all. he went all cross country season without socks.

anyways, i found it fair to the point that he answered it truthfully. there is proof, and either way, you could say that the answer could tell he was a male, depending on which approach you took to it.

[Phaelyn]

Mar 7, 2011 9:29:21 GMT -8 Mr. Spartan said:

Mar 7, 2011 9:26:13 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

I don't wear socks.

i only wear them when i run. i have a friend that doesn't wear them at all. he went all cross country season without socks.

anyways, i found it fair to the point that he answered it truthfully. there is proof, and either way, you could say that the answer could tell he was a male, depending on which approach you took to it.

Tell me how you can extrapolate 'definitely male' from 24 ribs.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Mar 7, 2011 8:58:46 GMT -8 Mr. Spartan said:

Mar 7, 2011 8:50:15 GMT -8 Pepper said:

I have a question. How does Syko saying he has 24 ribs answer whether he is male or female? XD 'Cause that definitely screwed us over.

his reasoning was that he had 24 ribs. all male and female humans have this amount. so he answered the question in a way he didn't have to tell what gender he was. he answered it truthfully, since men do have 24 ribs.

I call bs. You have to answer the question in a way that actually answers it. You can't avoid the answer like that, the rules say you must answer the question honestly. You can code it but it must answer the question. That doesn't answer the question unless you are female, show me one place where having 24 ribs proves you are male . Plus Syko didn't log in on night 2, so I don't know how he got his memo in to the narrator

So much for me being the psych, I suck at it

[Mr. Spartan]

Mar 7, 2011 9:37:02 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Mar 7, 2011 8:58:46 GMT -8 Mr. Spartan said:

his reasoning was that he had 24 ribs. all male and female humans have this amount. so he answered the question in a way he didn't have to tell what gender he was. he answered it truthfully, since men do have 24 ribs.

I call bs. You have to answer the question in a way that actually answers it. You can't avoid the answer like that, the rules say you must answer the question honestly. You can code it but it must answer the question. That doesn't answer the question unless you are female, show me one place where having 24 ribs proves you are male . Plus Syko didn't log in on night 2, so I don't know how he got his memo in to the narrator

So much for me being the psych, I suck at it

i think i got the pm in the morning. not sure. also, he'll be preparing a victory speech that will hopefully explain everything

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Mar 7, 2011 9:39:13 GMT -8 Mr. Spartan said:

Mar 7, 2011 9:37:02 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

I call bs. You have to answer the question in a way that actually answers it. You can't avoid the answer like that, the rules say you must answer the question honestly. You can code it but it must answer the question. That doesn't answer the question unless you are female, show me one place where having 24 ribs proves you are male . Plus Syko didn't log in on night 2, so I don't know how he got his memo in to the narrator

So much for me being the psych, I suck at it

i think i got the pm in the morning. not sure.

Well with those two bits of info and the fact that I wasn't sure if anyone actually voted for pepper the first time, people must be able to see my reasoning for picking her. This game is hard

Congrats Syko, you are truly deceptive

But I do think the rules about the questions should be made more clear. From the reasoning you gave us about that question, if I was the boss I could have been asked if was male and said "my hair is long" It's true, but it doesn't answer the question because women can have short hair, and men can have long hair, therefore I didn't answer anything. Perhaps this should be explained in more detail next round.

[Sir Neless]

I don't think she would of prepared a told you so image if she was the boss really

[Mr. Spartan]

Mar 7, 2011 9:40:38 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Mar 7, 2011 9:39:13 GMT -8 Mr. Spartan said:

i think i got the pm in the morning. not sure.

Well with those two bits of info and the fact that I wasn't sure if anyone actually voted for pepper the first time, people must be able to see my reasoning for picking her. This game is hard

Congrats Syko, you are truly deceptive

But I do think the rules about the questions should be made more clear. From the reasoning you gave us about that question, if I was the boss I could have been asked if was male and said "my hair is long" It's true, but it doesn't answer the question because women can have short hair, and men can have long hair, therefore I didn't answer anything. Perhaps this should be explained in more detail next round.

good point. there are a lot of things we need to work over before another game starts. (actually i think Trill mentioned something about a new one he made)

[Pepper]

-Muttermutterbitter- Still stupid to vote for the person who's been cleared... We coulda won, Dom! All glory to the employees! XD

Like I said, everyone was eager to jump on the Pepper bandwagon. I can't see how there was any doubt that I was voted for. =P

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Mar 7, 2011 9:54:48 GMT -8 Pepper said:

-Muttermutterbitter- Still stupid to vote for the person who's been cleared... We coulda won, Dom! All glory to the employees! XD

Like I said, everyone was eager to jump on the Pepper bandwagon. I can't see how there was any doubt that I was voted for. =P

I already said according to that one question, if it was answered HONESTLY and TRUTHFULLY, meant that only a female could have been the boss, and who's to say everyone voted for you, only the PM's count, someone could have lied. I would have been getting the same blame from Syko if you were the boss, he would have been using that question and the fact that he joined in 2009 as reasons why he couldn't have been the boss. You must see it from my perspective to truly understand how much of a crapshoot it really was.