Mafia v8 [Game over]

[Former Member]

RedBassett hasn't posted yet and Robert dealt the first accusation, which causes me to suspect one of them. Honestly, it's a long shot either way, but it's not like there's much else to go off of. 

[Robyn]

Wow @zar, talk about being very defensive when my claim wasn't anything to take seriously. Only a guilty troublemaker would jump to conclusions whenever his cover might be blown. -suspicious-

I was wrong last time about it being ZAR, and we won. So I'm sure if luck has it, I will be wrong again and someone else will come rescue us.

[Former Member]

Was ZAR that defensive last time you accused him? I think an innocent person, especially one falsely accused in the past, would be just as defensive as a guilty person, so I'm not sure we should count that against ZAR.

I'd rather not depend on someone else to come rescue us. We don't have that many people.

Would it be wiser to just avoid lynching someone until we have more to go off of? There's a 1/5 chance we'll get a mafia member, which isn't too bad, but would it be worth the risk of lessening our numbers by one more?

[Robyn]

Yeah I know it's risky and stupid just pointing fingers at members. We were super lucky last time to win the game in literately one round. We might not be as lucky this time. Normally rounds last for days, sometimes a week or two. Depends on how many people are playing and how well we each convince each other who's mafia or whatever.

[Former Member]

I'm just afraid we'll lynch our doctor. (Is there one this round?) We already lost our detective. D:

[RedBassett]

Look at me, being all suspicious. I'll point out that @kipp is asking us to not lynch anyone, so it could be her…

[Former Member]

Judging my everyones posts, our detectives death, and this bloody rod at Robyn's door I'll have to say RedBassett was innocent thus far.

With @kipp's lack of knowledge or a really great deceiving act, that she doesn't know if there is a Doctor, when it's posted on the front page.

So I will have to go with @zar final answer.

[Former Member]

RedBassett: Why would I try to convince everyone not to lynch anyone if I was mafia unless I was the suggested lynchee? (That's totally a word now, by the way.) If I was mafia, wouldn't it be playing right into my hands if you guys never missed a day killing each other off? Maybe I'm not seeing this from all angles, but it just seems like we're helping the mafia by killing someone without anything to go off of. Then again, I'll concede that we'll never really have a lot to go off of and inaction won't help us either.

@dmage: Yeah, I knew it was on the front page but I was too lazy to go back and check. xD Out of curiosity, are you voting ZAR because he defended himself when Robert accused him?

[Former Member]

Dec 19, 2014 0:01:46 GMT -8 @kipp said:

RedBassett: Why would I try to convince everyone not to lynch anyone if I was mafia unless I was the suggested lynchee? (That's totally a word now, by the way.) If I was mafia, wouldn't it be playing right into my hands if you guys never missed a day killing each other off? Maybe I'm not seeing this from all angles, but it just seems like we're helping the mafia by killing someone without anything to go off of. Then again, I'll concede that we'll never really have a lot to go off of and inaction won't help us either.

@dmage: Yeah, I knew it was on the front page but I was too lazy to go back and check. xD Out of curiosity, are you voting ZAR because he defended himself when Robert accused him?

Nope.

I accused him last time. Because I died first. I didn't die first, because he knew I was on to him last time. So why kill me and make me even more suspicious!?

If I die tomorrow. My last words will be ZAR DID IT!

[Former Member]

Dec 19, 2014 0:12:36 GMT -8 @dmage said:

My last words will be ZAR DID IT!

Or a mafia member trying to frame ZAR, haha. And "onto him"? I thought that RedBassett was the mafia dude last time? I don't understand. xD It's 2:30AM so I'm pretty much braindead.

But fair enough. I think that, if ZAR wasn't mafia last time, there's a better chance that he is this time. Despite RedBassett accusing me, I don't think he's mafia (for the same reason). If we're going to do a lynch without anything to go off of but chance, then chance it is. Also, ZAR hasn't posted since Robert's reply.

[Former Member]

MillsberryFan was calling my responsive defensive because it highlighted him as suspicious. It's obvious why I would defend myself, so that in itself is not suspicious. The thing that bothered Robyn was the fact that I highlighted him as potentially suspicious. 

I believe @kipp to have too much of an interest in the village well-being for her to be a suspect.

@dmage - you're 100% wrong, and the old game doesn't apply

I just have to say is don't be misled easily by Robyn, he's trying too hard to fit in.

He is my vote.

Robyn

[Former Member]

Less than ten hours to go before the day ends. Assuming that Robert votes for ZAR rather than himself, that's two votes for ZAR and one for Robert. So, after Robert's vote, we'll need just one more for ZAR to reach a majority. Or RedBassett and I could vote for Robert. I have all that right, don't I?

I'm about to get my little one ready for school and, following that, will likely be gone until an hour or so before the day phase ends, so it'd be really convenient if I could hear RedBassett's opinion before then. Between Robert and ZAR I have no idea which way to lean. *flip flops*

[Former Member]

Since it seems that @kipp & RedBassett will have the deciding vote, let me explain my thoughts:

Also it'd be worth @dmage reading this

Reasons why Robyn is probably mafia:

His first post in this game:

'-stands in the middle of the village, expecting someone to murder him within seconds and end the game amazingly fast, like last time-' 

- That's trying to fit in to the group too hard, he's already establishing himself as a villager. From the off. If he jokes that he could be Mafia then he surely can't be; right?! Wrong. That's a smokescreen. Robert joking about being a mafia member is supposed to lull us into a false sense of security, so that we don't suspect him - and believe he is a villager. 

The next post of Robert's accuses me of being the mafia member. He's tried to plant the seed/idea into all of you. - and it's working on some of you. Why would he start accusations so early, and what evidence did he have to suggest me? He just wanted you to start questioning/being suspicious of me to draw the attention away from him.

Also Robert said himself:

'Only a guilty troublemaker would jump to conclusions whenever his cover might be blown.'

That's exactly what he did. The second I challenged him, he jumped straight onto the it's ZAR bandwagon 

[Former Member]

Dec 19, 2014 5:37:22 GMT -8 @zar said:

Since it seems that @kipp & RedBassett will have the deciding vote, let me explain my thoughts:

Also it'd be worth @dmage reading this

Reasons why Robyn is probably mafia:

His first post in this game:

'-stands in the middle of the village, expecting someone to murder him within seconds and end the game amazingly fast, like last time-' 

- That's trying to fit in to the group too hard, he's already establishing himself as a villager. From the off. If he jokes that he could be Mafia then he surely can't be; right?! Wrong. That's a smokescreen. Robert joking about being a mafia member is supposed to lull us into a false sense of security, so that we don't suspect him - and believe he is a villager. 

The next post of Robert's accuses me of being the mafia member. He's tried to plant the seed/idea into all of you. - and it's working on some of you. Why would he start accusations so early, and what evidence did he have to suggest me? He just wanted you to start questioning/being suspicious of me to draw the attention away from him.

Also Robert said himself:

'Only a guilty troublemaker would jump to conclusions whenever his cover might be blown.'

That's exactly what he did. The second I challenged him, he jumped straight onto the it's ZAR bandwagon 

You're just ZAR haha. But no, my accusation isn't because of Robert.

But I will retract my vote (I mistyped vote for photo... Wut?) and say no one. And go a little closer. Since our detective is dead. I'll have to detect stuff.

Fish sticks anyone?

[Robyn]

Dec 19, 2014 5:37:22 GMT -8 @zar said:

Since it seems that @kipp & RedBassett will have the deciding vote, let me explain my thoughts:

Also it'd be worth @dmage reading this

Reasons why Robyn is probably mafia:

His first post in this game:

'-stands in the middle of the village, expecting someone to murder him within seconds and end the game amazingly fast, like last time-' 

- That's trying to fit in to the group too hard, he's already establishing himself as a villager. From the off. If he jokes that he could be Mafia then he surely can't be; right?! Wrong. That's a smokescreen. Robert joking about being a mafia member is supposed to lull us into a false sense of security, so that we don't suspect him - and believe he is a villager. 

The next post of Robert's accuses me of being the mafia member. He's tried to plant the seed/idea into all of you. - and it's working on some of you. Why would he start accusations so early, and what evidence did he have to suggest me? He just wanted you to start questioning/being suspicious of me to draw the attention away from him.

Also Robert said himself:

'Only a guilty troublemaker would jump to conclusions whenever his cover might be blown.'

That's exactly what he did. The second I challenged him, he jumped straight onto the it's ZAR bandwagon 

My first post was a bad attempt to RPG again. It's been two years since I've really gotten into a game like this and I was having fun. You should see what I did two years ago, myself and Nightwalker would post back to back interactions in my house and what we did. I think one time he was mafia too So you don't need to take that so seriously, I did that almost to entice whomever is mafia because our last game we won. The point of the mafia game is to have fun guessing who's getting killed so I was daring the mafia to target me. Which seems to be happening.

You are taking my RPG sentence waaaay too seriously

I did that as a joke. I accused you last time and someone suggested another member so as a joke I accused you again. It failed though because no one immediately suggested another person. I'm just trying to play long and have fun. If I honestly believe you were mafia, I would have immediately backed up my claim with facts and suggests. I obviously have no clue who's mafia (and if I were mafia, wouldn't I be more quiet like some other players are, waiting for people to vote?) and won't until people react to each other's votes and stuff, which is finally happening.

Haha nice use quoting me and using it against me. I guess I deserve that since I've done that over and over two years ago. Is that revenge? Haha. Anyway I still don't really have any particular vote but some people think it's you, ZAR... let me post this and review the other replies again.

Okay so I checked the previous replies and I guess if I vote for ZAR then only one other person needs to. But Nick doesn't want to vote for anyone. Anything could look suspicious in this thread, really.

I don't see any bolded votes. I want to see confirmations for votes.