Mafia IX: Judgment Day [Terminated]

[Capitan]

Dec 31, 2014 17:48:53 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Okay, nerds, here we go. I'm around the next 6 hours or so, but I plan to sleep in tomorrow, so let's get some debate done now

I'm not making any strong claims in this department, but despite ZAR's death, I do at least partially buy Jaguar 's claim that she was trying to shake something loose. (Further, I think we'd just be playing into the mafia's hands if we killed her instead.)

That's the crux of the thing, isn't it- the mafia seem to want us to think ZAR was onto something? We can revisit Sugilite later if suspicions arise, but for now I would say it'd make more sense to stray away from the direction the mafia are pointing...

I have a few other suspicions right now, but I think our best bet would be to take out Ajay. He hasn't posted in this thread once but has posted around GT since the game started, which means he either forgot completely and therefore isn't contributing to our cause OR is a mafia member who's trying to go unnoticed. (I recognize that he could also be the detective, but he's sure not doing a good job if he isn't PMing people he's cleared or trying to push the vote towards a confirmed mafia member.) Overall, unless anyone else has a better idea or Ajay has a really good explanation, I say we lynch him.

This works for me, I think. We've still yet to actually lynch anyone- we need to crack this open, rather than let the mafia keep killing off the stronger players. If anything, the recrimations and accusations ought to provide useful clues as to who is mafia.

Ajay

[Søren]

Either way Ajay isn't helping much, or trying to get by through stealth so

Ajay

[Syko Nachoman]

Good timing, self. I found this at 2:11pm, and yesterday's timestamp was 2:10pm.

Anyway, time for your daily spinning newspaper:

Ajay Lynched by Angry Mob

An unruly mobbed today turned on Ajay, accusing him and his idleness of the three recent murders. A sniper was hired to shoot Ajay through the sunroof of his pricey house, where he had spent the past three days holed up, speaking to no one and seemingly doing very little. Upon further investigation, however, the villagers discovered a slew of medical equipment as well as a nearly-finished cure for every cancer known to man, suggesting that Ajay had actually been a respected doctor performing important medical work. Oops.

---

@dmage Phaelyn Graham Capitan Jaguar RedBassett Søren

Night 4 has begun. Night roles, etc.

[Former Member]

........ *sigh*

*sleeps*

[Phaelyn]

Whoops.

[Jaguar]

OOPS..... *Back to the drawing Board*

[Søren]

): *sleeps*

[Capitan]

Well... crap.

[Syko Nachoman]

Does the RedBassett Die?

The answer is yes. (And he was a regular villager.)

---

@dmage Phaelyn Graham Capitan Jaguar Søren

Day 4 has begun. Take 24 hours and decide who to kill. A majority will require four votes.

Note: Lynching a villager will result in a Mafia win, because two more villager deaths will equalize the numbers, so choose carefully if you're a villager or deceptively if you're Mafia. Without a doctor, the Mafia is guaranteed a successful kill at night.

[Phaelyn]

OK, detective, now's the time to make yourself known and lead the charge.

[Former Member]

I'll have to vote for Phea. Why? She was the first to vote for Ajay, he was our doctor. And how could she know that if she wasn't Mafia.

This is a huge gamble. And if I see any other reason to change my response I will. But for now its gonna be Phea.

[Phaelyn]

Jan 2, 2015 11:23:34 GMT -8 @dmage said:

I'll have to vote for Phea. Why? She was the first to vote for Ajay, he was our doctor. And how could she know that if she wasn't Mafia.

This is a huge gamble. And if I see any other reason to change my response I will. But for now its gonna be Phea.

You guys saw my reasoning and thought it was sound -- this isn't solely on me. No one else was stepping up, so I felt someone had to (story of my life). Also, how would 1. I know he was the doctor 2. anyone in the mafia know he was the doctor anyways? I'm tentatively voting for Nick now, though again, I am 100% open to changing if someone comes in here with some reasons pointing towards someone else. 

[Former Member]

Jan 2, 2015 12:02:19 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Jan 2, 2015 11:23:34 GMT -8 @dmage said:

I'll have to vote for Phea. Why? She was the first to vote for Ajay, he was our doctor. And how could she know that if she wasn't Mafia.

This is a huge gamble. And if I see any other reason to change my response I will. But for now its gonna be Phea.

You guys saw my reasoning and thought it was sound -- this isn't solely on me. No one else was stepping up, so I felt someone had to (story of my life). Also, how would 1. I know he was the doctor 2. anyone in the mafia know he was the doctor anyways? I'm tentatively voting for Nick now, though again, I am 100% open to changing if someone comes in here with some reasons pointing towards someone else. 

You also want the detective to reveal themselves which wouldn't be a good idea. If the detective dies, that's it for us.

Also voting for me will make us villagers lose this one. So far we have won each game thus far as villagers. I've never been selected as a special role.

[Phaelyn]

Jan 2, 2015 12:44:41 GMT -8 @dmage said:

Jan 2, 2015 12:02:19 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

You guys saw my reasoning and thought it was sound -- this isn't solely on me. No one else was stepping up, so I felt someone had to (story of my life). Also, how would 1. I know he was the doctor 2. anyone in the mafia know he was the doctor anyways? I'm tentatively voting for Nick now, though again, I am 100% open to changing if someone comes in here with some reasons pointing towards someone else. 

You also want the detective to reveal themselves which wouldn't be a good idea. If the detective dies, that's it for us.

Also voting for me will make us villagers lose this one. So far we have won each game thus far as villagers. I've never been selected as a special role.

Read Syko's post. If we don't get a mafia member tonight, that's already it for us Also, your past roles have absolutely no bearing on your current one.

[Former Member]

Jan 2, 2015 13:05:23 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Jan 2, 2015 12:44:41 GMT -8 @dmage said:

You also want the detective to reveal themselves which wouldn't be a good idea. If the detective dies, that's it for us.

Also voting for me will make us villagers lose this one. So far we have won each game thus far as villagers. I've never been selected as a special role.

Read Syko's post. If we don't get a mafia member tonight, that's already it for us Also, your past roles have absolutely no bearing on your current one.

Right either way we might end up losing. And of course it doesn't. I'm just sad I'm not special for special roles.