Mafia v10 [Done]

[Syko Nachoman]

Now Phaelyn Is the One Who Is It

Unfortunately, she was the doctor. No special roles aside from Mafia remain.

---

Robyn Søren Graham Capitan

Day 4 has begun. Because there are only three regular villagers left and the doctor is dead, if a villager is lynched today, the Mafia will win during the night phase. This can be prevented by lynching a Mafia member (village wins) or with no lynch (game continues for another day).

[Graham]

Crikey, right we have to get it right this time folks.

[Robyn]

Well, since nothing's really happening yet I'll start out with my vote for Graham. The reason is because Day 3 he voted me and I asked why but he remained silent until night came, to which he was the first to respond with disappointment from the day's lack of lynching someone. I just find that odd.

[Graham]

Jan 19, 2015 16:19:50 GMT -8 Robyn said:

Well, since nothing's really happening yet I'll start out with my vote for Graham. The reason is because Day 3 he voted me and I asked why but he remained silent until night came, to which he was the first to respond with disappointment from the day's lack of lynching someone. I just find that odd.

My reason for disappointment was that we didn't lynch anyone, therefore missing an opportunity to get rid of a mafia member. If I were mafia and thought it was you, I would have taken you out by now Also I nominated Nick first who was mafia, I wouldn't bump off one of my own knowingly.
I chose you originally as I wasn't 100% convinced you weren't mafia I'm not sure who is to be fair.

[Søren]

Aw Phaelyn was only one I was fairly sure it wasn't.

Think I wait to vote for while, or maybe we should go for a no lynch, it get us one more day where as a wrong vote we lose

[Capitan]

Robert's reason to vote Graham is so ridiculous that I'm gonna vote for him.

Soren - Definitely not another no lynch tonight. I really have no idea who to vote, but let's not cede the initiative again. I'd rather get it wrong tonight and lose.

Sod it- voting Graham. I just want something to happen.

[Graham]

I can see where this is going, but it would be a wasted vote and still leave you searching for a mafia member.

My vote goes to Soren.

[Capitan]

Actually, that makes more sense. Soren's tactic seems similar to the previous game and he's had a low profile throughout this one. Voting soren.

[Syko Nachoman]

Day 4 Ends Without Lunch

Or a lynch, either.

---

Robyn Søren Graham Capitan

Night 5 has begun. Night roles, etc.

Because there will only be three players alive during Day 5, a majority will need to vote for the remaining Mafia member to win. Otherwise, the Mafia wins, either through the lynching of a villager or, in the case of no vote, through the Night 6 kill.

[Syko Nachoman]

Graham Is Also Dead Now

And then there were three.

---

Robyn Søren Capitan

Day 5, etc. It will end 24 hours from the timestamp of this post, so remember that no additional votes, vote changes, retractions, etc. will count after that time.

[Syko Nachoman]

[Capitan]

Voting Robert.

[Søren]

I don't know..

voting Capitan

you voted for Robert, then when Graham voted for me you were very quick to change and do the same, im a villager so if there was a lynch we would have lost

[Capitan]

Here's my reasoning:

Robert voted for Graham. I followed him, hoping to secure a vote- any vote, because I wanted to raise peoples voices into revealing their hand. Then Graham voted for you, and I switched to follow him because I felt Graham was less suspicious than you were (this turned out to be true). Graham died and turned out to be a villager- and hence Robert's initial vote for him looks suspicious to me. Notice how he hasn't voted yet? The Mafia literally only has to vote this round of the two voters are pointing different directions- what we are doing. If we can't decide, the Mafia automatically wins. So I suspect Robert, and suggest you do the same. Obviously you have to take it on trust that I'm a villager, but I can assure you that my vote meandering last round was simple uncertainty.

Apologies for the word soup, posting on phone in a hurry.

[Robyn]

Jan 22, 2015 2:00:50 GMT -8 Søren said:

I don't know..

voting Capitan

you voted for Robert, then when Graham voted for me you were very quick to change and do the same, im a villager so if there was a lynch we would have lost

I noticed how Capitan said "Sod it- voting Graham. I just want something to happen." and then when it was clear he wasn't going to get lynched, he just chose to kill Graham in the night phase. That's my guess.

I'm curious why he'd vote for me and not you in the day round.

I'll vote for Capitan as well.

Also, sorry for the inactivity recently, in real life I just got a local job and have been going through training.

Jan 22, 2015 9:46:21 GMT -8 Capitan said:

Here's my reasoning:

Robert voted for Graham. I followed him, hoping to secure a vote- any vote, because I wanted to raise peoples voices into revealing their hand. Then Graham voted for you, and I switched to follow him because I felt Graham was less suspicious than you were (this turned out to be true). Graham died and turned out to be a villager- and hence Robert's initial vote for him looks suspicious to me. Notice how he hasn't voted yet? The Mafia literally only has to vote this round of the two voters are pointing different directions- what we are doing. If we can't decide, the Mafia automatically wins. So I suspect Robert, and suggest you do the same. Obviously you have to take it on trust that I'm a villager, but I can assure you that my vote meandering last round was simple uncertainty.

Apologies for the word soup, posting on phone in a hurry.

Forgot to refresh the post before I left for job training and once I posted the above, yours came up. My bad

I explained why I voted for Graham I wasn't sure if he was mafia or not. All of us have been voting for villagers by mistake throughout the game, so my one mistake guessing Graham was mafia shouldn't been seen any more suspicious than you or Soren's votes. I hadn't voted until now because of a new job I got to pay for spring semester of college in real life. I've been away from keyboard a lot.

At this point we either catch the mafia or we die.