ProBoards Mafia 3 : TMM (Post-Game)

[Dove]

Ohhh...nvm sarcasm....

[Phaelyn]

Jan 12, 2011 16:23:32 GMT -8 Trill said:

Jan 12, 2011 16:19:23 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Resorting to sarcasm and roll-eye smilies is always the best defense.

Yeah, I'm on the defensive. You're manipulating people, no offense. You're making it sound like everyone I PMd was trying to get conned by me. I also never mass-PMd the same message. I thought that was worthy to be repeated.

Regarding my sarcasm, it's due to the fact that I find your evidence unfounded, illogical, and just wrong.

The Evidence against me is that I PMd a bunch of people. Many of the PMs were were either anti-alliance, or my suspicions about who was in the alliance, for security in case I was killed during the night.

Why would you have been killed in the night, though? Speaking of, you ignored my question about your mention of being an important villager.

[**hp]

Jan 12, 2011 16:24:01 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Voting So Far

4 Votes for Trill - Phaelyn, Pat's fReak, Ricky, Dom
2 Votes for Crow - **HP, Trill
0 Votes for No Lynch -
14 No Votes (no Lynch)

11 Votes Required

As if that doesn't look suspicious. I'm retracting my vote for the time being.

[Robyn]

Just to clarify, I assume you are allowed to vote for the majority vote (especially if you have to leave or won't be on for a while, etc?)

[Ace Trainer Dom]

OH GOD! ROBERT IS STILL ALIVE!!! WE SHOULD LYNCH HIM, HE MUST BE MAFIA!!!


See? I can make stupid accusations too

Why don't we take everything down a notch and try and sort this out better, because I can honestly say if this continues we are going to make a mistake.

(And sorry Robert, but I wanted to use something and you were the most recent post )

[aether]

Alright,

1) Phaelyn: We only lose the doctor if the doctor dies in my plan. The doctor isn't revealed. What happens is that once there is a leader, it becomes a hunt for the doctor instead. That doesn't automatically mean the doctor is going to die. (If I understand your complaint correctly)

2) Dom: there's a reason you're the first person to suspect me of being in the mafia and that's because I'm not in the mafia. I have provided mafia hunting plans and I have kept up a network of villagers (mostly, hopefully)

3) Trill: The reason I've kept that I'm working with people and with whom I'm working is because I have only contacted who I have reasonable believe that they're innocent. And to reveal them would put a target on their back, because they know that those members are working together.

[iCraft]

I just want every one to know i have been off because of the weather and my Internet wouldnt load, And i have got a really weird message from Less Then Three.

[Trill]

I'm changing my vote to Phaelyn. She is adamantly against me based on unsound evidence.

So I was snooping around about an alliance. I wanted to stop the back room decisions that pretty much ran the game. I wanted to have an influence in the game and not be a pawn to the big secret alliance.

Phaelyn seems to want me to stop my snooping, and not uncover who really is in the alliance or what they know. Fits the mafia role in the alliance perfectly.

Jan 12, 2011 16:26:07 GMT -8 Robyn said:

Just to clarify, I assume you are allowed to vote for the majority vote (especially if you have to leave or won't be on for a while, etc?)

It's a great way for the mafia to have more influence...

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Jan 12, 2011 16:28:30 GMT -8 aether said:

Alright,

1) Phaelyn: We only lose the doctor if the doctor dies in my plan. The doctor isn't revealed. What happens is that once there is a leader, it becomes a hunt for the doctor instead. That doesn't automatically mean the doctor is going to die. (If I understand your complaint correctly)

2) Dom: there's a reason you're the first person to suspect me of being in the mafia and that's because I'm not in the mafia. I have provided mafia hunting plans and I have kept up a network of villagers (mostly, hopefully)

3) Trill: The reason I've kept that I'm working with people and with whom I'm working is because I have only contacted who I have reasonable believe that they're innocent. And to reveal them would put a target on their back, because they know that those members are working together.

To be fair I will explain why. I am in a PM convo with one person this game. That person spoke in the previous day to me saying if she were to die then I should make sure you are lynched. That's really all I have on you, but something must have made her send that to me

[CheatAreZee]

Note for future: Dom defends Trill as well.

Jan 12, 2011 16:28:51 GMT -8 iCraft said:

I just want every one to know i have been off because of the weather and my Internet wouldnt load, And i have got a really weird message from Less Then Three.

Care to share the message?

[Trill]

Aether, I know you aren't mafia, but how do you know Phaelyn isn't, and the members in the upper ranks of your alliance aren't?

[Phaelyn]

Go ahead and try to kill me, it'll accomplish nothing. I'm a villager with the village elder secondary role. I'm being adamant because you're being really damn suspicious and are backing it up with no evidence.

Anyway, what I'm getting at is you guys will have to leave me be unless you want to waste your vote for 2 days. If you don't want to vote for Trill, I suggest voting for Crow. And of course, if you really want to test this theory, I'm not gonna stop you. I'll pull a patrick and die for the greater good, haha.

[aether]

Jan 12, 2011 16:29:57 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Jan 12, 2011 16:28:30 GMT -8 aether said:

Alright,

1) Phaelyn: We only lose the doctor if the doctor dies in my plan. The doctor isn't revealed. What happens is that once there is a leader, it becomes a hunt for the doctor instead. That doesn't automatically mean the doctor is going to die. (If I understand your complaint correctly)

2) Dom: there's a reason you're the first person to suspect me of being in the mafia and that's because I'm not in the mafia. I have provided mafia hunting plans and I have kept up a network of villagers (mostly, hopefully)

3) Trill: The reason I've kept that I'm working with people and with whom I'm working is because I have only contacted who I have reasonable believe that they're innocent. And to reveal them would put a target on their back, because they know that those members are working together.

To be fair I will explain why. I am in a PM convo with one person this game. That person spoke in the previous day to me saying if she were to die then I should make sure you are lynched. That's really all I have on you, but something must have made her send that to me

I know who you're talking about and why you're talking about them. Them dying isn't something I'm really worried about.

Can people stop using gender-specific pronouns?

[Thesealion]

Trill you asked were you said that it was only one or two people. Look at my last post...

[Phaelyn]

I'm pretty sure I've already worked out who you're talking about, anyway, but that's besides the point, haha.