ProBoards Mafia 3 : TMM (Post-Game)

[Phaelyn]

Trill, that still loses us the doctor after a day

[Trill]

Jan 12, 2011 16:03:45 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Jan 12, 2011 16:00:36 GMT -8 Robyn said:

Can someone quickly summarize who has died in this game and what they were?

Check the first page


trill -- actually, no, I know I wouldn't have. I've been selectively PMing several members, but I never once denied it to any of them. For the ones I trusted more, I even named names and sent out a few group PMs. If someone had asked me in the thread, I would have openly admitted it, too!

As I said, for me to believe you? You're going to need more substantial evidence. You dug this hole for yourself, pull yourself out

Also, I question why you would have pm'd nearly EVERYone if you weren't exactly sure of who's in this malevolent alliance.



Obviously you wouldn't leave two players out from the list. Say they're villagers or something. I'm not the one who decided to go around and compile a list of roles in a big alliance...

Obviously that's impossible because the list of what roles are left is absolutely public and the lack of such roles would be as telling as complete ommitance of those members

(ps please don't use the roll-eyes smiley )[/quote]
I PMd less than half of the players in the game. Don't be so analytical and start a tally, it's an estimate. It seems like a lot because most of them have already posted in here. Most of the PMs they're thinking 'support' evidence against me, but have you even read the PMs?

Sure, this is my first game and I wanted to be secure. So I PMd a lot of people. I won't deny it. Does that mean I'm a mafia member? No!

Jan 12, 2011 16:07:04 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Trill, that still loses us the doctor after a day

So you're saying Aether's original strategy is flawed, so you blame me?

[Thesealion]

Jan 12, 2011 16:00:48 GMT -8 Trill said:

Jan 12, 2011 15:57:00 GMT -8 Thesealion said:

[/b][/color][/quote]
Yeah. I sent that particular PM not only to you, but to one or two others.

Was I supposed to NOT be worried after I accused the biggest alliance/network in the game about some mafia activity?

Seriously, look it at from my point of view. I accused someone in the biggest alliance last round. Do you think that made me feel comfortable during the night? I wanted you and several others to know who I thought was in the alliance in case I was killed.

This "evidence" against me is useless. No offense. Anyone would have done that in my shoes.[/quote]

But why did you say that me and ONE other person knew...

Frankly i could believe both sides on this one but the PM's have me held up. Why didn't you just tell the truth to everyone?

[Phaelyn]

Jan 12, 2011 16:08:14 GMT -8 Trill said:

Jan 12, 2011 16:03:45 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Check the first page


trill -- actually, no, I know I wouldn't have. I've been selectively PMing several members, but I never once denied it to any of them. For the ones I trusted more, I even named names and sent out a few group PMs. If someone had asked me in the thread, I would have openly admitted it, too!

As I said, for me to believe you? You're going to need more substantial evidence. You dug this hole for yourself, pull yourself out

Also, I question why you would have pm'd nearly EVERYone if you weren't exactly sure of who's in this malevolent alliance.

Obviously you wouldn't leave two players out from the list. Say they're villagers or something. I'm not the one who decided to go around and compile a list of roles in a big alliance...

Obviously that's impossible because the list of what roles are left is absolutely public and the lack of such roles would be as telling as complete ommitance of those members

(ps please don't use the roll-eyes smiley )

I PMd less than half of the players in the game. Don't be so analytical and start a tally, it's an estimate. It seems like a lot because most of them have already posted in here. Most of the PMs they're thinking 'support' evidence against me, but have you even read the PMs?

Sure, this is my first game and I wanted to be secure. So I PMd a lot of people. I won't deny it. Does that mean I'm a mafia member? No!

-headdesk-

No, I didn't take the time to count them out. You still PM'd a substantial amount of members! I know of at LEAST three more that haven't signed on/come forward yet.

And i told you already that saying that anyone would've done it or whatever isn't really evidence to me. Really and you did pretty much deny it in every one of your PMs.

Me
Ricky
Capitan
Nightwalker
maybe some other people i can't remember and can't be bothered to read again at the moment
3 people besides that

That's FAR more than the one or two other people you mentioned in the PMs.

[tercielsilvi]

Jan 12, 2011 16:12:08 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Jan 12, 2011 16:08:14 GMT -8 Trill said:

Obviously that's impossible because the list of what roles are left is absolutely public and the lack of such roles would be as telling as complete ommitance of those members

(ps please don't use the roll-eyes smiley )

I PMd less than half of the players in the game. Don't be so analytical and start a tally, it's an estimate. It seems like a lot because most of them have already posted in here. Most of the PMs they're thinking 'support' evidence against me, but have you even read the PMs?

Sure, this is my first game and I wanted to be secure. So I PMd a lot of people. I won't deny it. Does that mean I'm a mafia member? No!

-headdesk-

No, I didn't take the time to count them out. You still PM'd a substantial amount of members! I know of at LEAST three more that haven't signed on/come forward yet.

And i told you already that saying that anyone would've done it or whatever isn't really evidence to me. Really and you did pretty much deny it in every one of your PMs.

Me
Ricky
Capitan
some other people i can't remember and can't be bothered to read again at the moment
3 people besides that

That's FAR more than the one or two other people you mentioned in the PMs.

I think this list of who Trill PM'd would be a lot more useful if we knew what days they were sent. I recieved mine during Day 2, as I said.

[Phaelyn]

Got mine around 10pm EST on Monday. (just checked -- that was day 2, i think?)

[Trill]

In what PM did I ever say "one or two people" - I never mass-sent any particular PM. And so what? I PMd a bunch. I PMd some duplicate PMs. Others were unique. Are you saying that's supposed to incriminate me? There were a lot of PMs I sent to two-three people. I NEVER sent the same PM to more than three-four people, like Phaelyn is trying to make it sound.

Phaelyn, this is NOT evidence that I'm a mafia member.

Hey, how about everyone posts their PMs from Phaelyn here?


edit: So Capitan got my PM on day two. Take that name off the list. At that time I knew nothing of the big alliance.

[Phaelyn]

I'll post every single one if you'd like, but I doubt you'd want to see over two pages. I do a lot of PMing inside and outside of the mafia game, recently.

[Trill]

Jan 12, 2011 16:17:56 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

I'll post every single one if you'd like, but I doubt you'd want to see over two pages. I do a lot of PMing inside and outside of the mafia game, recently.

Oh, you PM people! Let's vote Phaelyn!

[tercielsilvi]

Jan 12, 2011 16:16:24 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Got mine around 10pm EST on Monday. (just checked -- that was day 2, i think?)

Which in-game day does that correspond to? I'm in a different timezone to you.

ed; you edited, ignore this post

[Phaelyn]

Jan 12, 2011 16:18:47 GMT -8 Trill said:

Jan 12, 2011 16:17:56 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

I'll post every single one if you'd like, but I doubt you'd want to see over two pages. I do a lot of PMing inside and outside of the mafia game, recently.

Oh, you PM people! Let's vote Phaelyn!

Resorting to sarcasm and roll-eye smilies is always the best defense.

[Dove]

Trill why are you nominating phaelyn? What has she done so far to be suspicious ?

[CheatAreZee]

It's not about any alliance, it's more about who knew of what roles players had. The Mafia had to of known Zar wasn't a standard villager; he only had what, 2 posts this whole game? Someone a lot more prominent should have been a target. There's no way the Zar pick by the mafia was just a coincidence

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Good god, I go shopping for a half hour and this erupts

Why don't we just take EVERYBODY out who has ever communicated via PM. Oh wait, that's all of us . Point is Trill, that people seems to believe that you were misleading them in your PMs to them. They wanted to remain in the loop, and by not even telling them when circumstances changed you are showing that you don't trust ANY of them. If that's the case, why PM anybody at all?

[Trill]

Jan 12, 2011 16:19:23 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Jan 12, 2011 16:18:47 GMT -8 Trill said:

Oh, you PM people! Let's vote Phaelyn!

Resorting to sarcasm and roll-eye smilies is always the best defense.

Yeah, I'm on the defensive. You're manipulating people, no offense. You're making it sound like everyone I PMd was trying to get conned by me. I also never mass-PMd the same message. I thought that was worthy to be repeated.

Regarding my sarcasm, it's due to the fact that I find your evidence unfounded, illogical, and just wrong.

The Evidence against me is that I PMd a bunch of people. Many of the PMs were were either anti-alliance, or my suspicions about who was in the alliance, for security in case I was killed during the night.