ProBoards Mafia 3 : TMM (Post-Game)

[Trill]

Jan 12, 2011 16:40:07 GMT -8 Thesealion said:

Jan 12, 2011 16:38:11 GMT -8 Trill said:

I'm not arguing if this is true or not, but right when the suspicion starts to turn towards you, you leave. It's no fun to debate someone who isn't here.

When did the Suspicion go there? I didn't notice...

BTW you never answered my question...from like 2 posts ago

If you link to the post, I'd be happy to answer your question. It'd be hard for me to find the specific question to which you are referring "from like 2 posts ago."

[aether]

I'm going to have to vote for Dom.

His sarcastic replies aren't doing much for me, as well as the reasons I mentioned earlier.

[Dove]

I'm so confused here. There are like four different arguments going on at once, most stemming at trill and phaelyn.

Convince me trill why I shouldn't vote you...

[Robyn]

Æther, my sincere apologizes if I'm wrong but didn't you rationalize way back at day 1 that patrick was mafia?

[Trill]

Phaelyn, like I said, I was not arguing against your statement about having a final. You're trying to turn everything I say against me now.

I'm a regular villager. I told you (AS WELL AS MEMBERS I THOUGHT TO BE BIG ALLIANCE, so don't claim that I'm mass PMing people with different stories) I had a special role only (I NEVER specified which one) because I wanted to see what information the big alliance had. Again, this comes down to my motive to get the "safe" secret alliance information public.

Does anyone here approve of a secret alliance of several people, possibly including mafia, running the game and knowing all the information that isn't public? I already expressed my two inherent concerns about this alliance in one of my earlier posts this part of the round.

[Ryan Roos]

Voting So Far

4 Votes for Trill - Phaelyn, Pat's Freak, Ricky, Dom
1 Votes for Phaelyn - Trill
1 vote for Dom - Aether
0 Votes for No Lynch -
14 No Votes (no Lynch)

11 Votes Required

[Dove]

Trill what I ask is why you think there's this big alliance?

[iCraft]

I have to say its going to make me look guilty But i think trill is right and i also think i know what his role is

[tercielsilvi]

Jan 12, 2011 16:47:46 GMT -8 Trill said:

Does anyone here approve of a secret alliance of several people, possibly including mafia, running the game and knowing all the information that isn't public? I already expressed my two inherent concerns about this alliance in one of my earlier posts this part of the round.

Whilst I can certainly see the benefits, it seems fairly evident that there is a mafia element to it and as such highly diminishes any bonuses that it brings.

[Thesealion]

Jan 12, 2011 16:47:46 GMT -8 Trill said:

Phaelyn, like I said, I was not arguing against your statement about having a final. You're trying to turn everything I say against me now.

I'm a regular villager. I told you (AS WELL AS MEMBERS I THOUGHT TO BE BIG ALLIANCE, so don't claim that I'm mass PMing people with different stories) I had a special role only (I NEVER specified which one) because I wanted to see what information the big alliance had. Again, this comes down to my motive to get the "safe" secret alliance information public.

Does anyone here approve of a secret alliance of several people, possibly including mafia, running the game and knowing all the information that isn't public? I already expressed my two inherent concerns about this alliance in one of my earlier posts this part of the round.

But i see you as the person


who you should be worried about...anyone else that has talked to me has not asked for any info...you seemed to be wanting me to give something away and when i didn't you lost interest...

My question was why did you say in your PM to me that me and ONE other person would know your suspects? First off you never gave suspects and second of all more than one person was getting pm's from you...

Am i misunderstanding what you are saying?

[Robyn]

Jan 12, 2011 16:50:11 GMT -8 iCraft said:

I have to say its going to make me look guilty But i think trill is right and i also think i know what his role is

Trill PMed me asking for trust (essentially) so yeah...

[Trill]

Jan 12, 2011 16:48:59 GMT -8 Dove said:

Trill what I ask is why you think there's this big alliance?

It's proven. See my post here: support.proboards.com/index.cgi?action=display&board=games&thread=378950&page=33#4308677
Aether has since mentioned the alliance.

[Trill]

Jan 12, 2011 16:51:18 GMT -8 Robyn said:

Jan 12, 2011 16:50:11 GMT -8 iCraft said:

I have to say its going to make me look guilty But i think trill is right and i also think i know what his role is

Trill PMed me asking for trust (essentially) so yeah...

No I didn't. Post the PM.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Jan 12, 2011 16:46:35 GMT -8 aether said:

I'm going to have to vote for Dom.

His sarcastic replies aren't doing much for me, as well as the reasons I mentioned earlier.

Don't like sarcasm? That's all I'm seeing in this thread I'll vote myself too if it comes to it, this game is getting crazy and there are simply waaay too many people in this one. It's getting out of hand imo.

[Robyn]

Okay then:

Robert...

Okay, you're probably going to share this PM I'm sending you just to make me look more suspicious, but whatever, haha

What do you think about the game?

It looks like we're both suspects for illogical reasons. You, for just being alive, and me because I PMd a bunch of people, haha.

To me it just seems like that. To me, Pming anyone when you are mafia (or not) asking for trust just isn't the right move.