ProBoards Mafia 3 : TMM (Post-Game)

[CheatAreZee]

(4 pages already? Jebus )

At this point in the game, I don't think there will be much evidence for anyone, so if we do lynch someone it'll be on a good guess. I'll wait for Robert's reply before going with the vote for him.

[Ren Rudner]

I agree with Ricky. Whatever we decide it's really just going to be a guess because it's so early in the game.

But voting for someone based on what was said in the obituary that Ryan wrote would be dumb. He just made up the thing about the cats. I don't think it's any sort of hint or anything.

[tercielsilvi]

Here are the facts we have so far:

• There are 26 people left in the village. Five of these are mafia, meaning that there is a 19% chance that a random lynch would be beneficial for the village.
  
• No-one has claimed to be the detective, this is most likely because their investigation turned up a villager, and it is not yet advantageous for the mafia to claim to be so.
  
• Because of this, it really is a case of just choosing a person at random. I am inclined not to vote Robert because he got killed first in all the previous games, and we really have no leads.
  

[Robyn]

*wakes up hearing shouting outside. Goes outside to see everyone pointing at him with anger*

What the? Haha I finally survived the first round! And to my dismay everyone is point at me

What's this BS about me hating cats? I LOVE cats!!! Seriously, I had a stuffed animal kitten who I named Arthur. I've probably posted on here before about liking cats. My dad's allergic so I can't have one though. Kittens are my favorite.

Just search on Proboards for pet topics. In fact, there was a topic I made last year around fall where my mom was saying that she thinks dogs are more popular than cats, and so I made a poll and thought that cats were better

Plus how about this:

support.proboards.com/index.cgi?action=display&board=pbgt&thread=376096&page=3#4268467

I could show you photos on my computer of me with my kitten toy but I don't know if that's allowed in the game.

Thus based on the BS that Adam is saying about me hating cats, I vote for Adam

[Andrea]

Jan 10, 2011 11:29:36 GMT -8 @tercielsilvi said:

Here are the facts we have so far:

• There are 26 people left in the village. Five of these are mafia, meaning that there is a 19% chance that a random lynch would be beneficial for the village.
  
• No-one has claimed to be the detective, this is most likely because their investigation turned up a villager, and it is not yet advantageous for the mafia to claim to be so.
  
• Because of this, it really is a case of just choosing a person at random. I am inclined not to vote Robert because he got killed first in all the previous games, and we really have no leads.
  

You forget that we know Crow is the mayor as well, so 25 villagers are left, 5 of which are in the mafia.

[Ryan Roos]

CLARIFICATION : Newspaper articles will not reveal clues to suspects. Bagheera is a tiger. Bagheera the person has a cat (tiger) for her avatar. Hence cats are relevant for the story. The gun shots were heard because Bagheera went to sleep with a .45 Colt under her pillow. I try to make the articles relevant to what you guys role play and who the victims are.

I lol'd at this cat thing being brought up at all. Last game the deaths and reports were crazy and no one ever thought a part was relevant to any suspects.

You guys are all silly.

[Adam]

Jan 10, 2011 11:07:16 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Jan 10, 2011 10:43:36 GMT -8 aether said:

I don't think Robert is in the mafia. I mean, he could be, I suppose. But since his abilities to point out the mafia is wholly unproven because of his bad luck (or a conspiracy), I think that it's much more reasonable for a mafia member to take out a proven mafia hunter like Bagheera.

Also, I think that because Bagheera was killed, a potential majority of the mafia is from the first game because they witnessed how well Bagheera did. However, it could just be a group of mafia members who read through the whole first game, which seems less likely because it was 30+ pages long.

Looking at this, I recommend that if I get killed, you should all try to kill some mafia from last game. As you said, though, that was at least 50 pages (if I remember correctly). That's pretty much the only way they would have identified her as a large threat, haha.

Personally, I have no ideas so far, though. I think killing Robert at this stage would be a bit unfair, as at this early we really have absolutely no evidence

How predictable. Not that I should need to say it at this point, but another dog lover defends Robert (take note of Phaelyn's sig). You are all so transparent. This is too easy!

[Andrea]

Jan 10, 2011 11:35:56 GMT -8 Adam said:

Jan 10, 2011 11:07:16 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Looking at this, I recommend that if I get killed, you should all try to kill some mafia from last game. As you said, though, that was at least 50 pages (if I remember correctly). That's pretty much the only way they would have identified her as a large threat, haha.

Personally, I have no ideas so far, though. I think killing Robert at this stage would be a bit unfair, as at this early we really have absolutely no evidence

How predictable. Not that I should need to say it at this point, but another dog lover defends Robert (take note of Phaelyn's sig). You are all so transparent. This is too easy!

I was almost thinking the same thing.

[Robyn]

Jan 10, 2011 11:35:56 GMT -8 Adam said:

Jan 10, 2011 11:07:16 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Looking at this, I recommend that if I get killed, you should all try to kill some mafia from last game. As you said, though, that was at least 50 pages (if I remember correctly). That's pretty much the only way they would have identified her as a large threat, haha.

Personally, I have no ideas so far, though. I think killing Robert at this stage would be a bit unfair, as at this early we really have absolutely no evidence

How predictable. Not that I should need to say it at this point, but another dog lover defends Robert. You are all so transparent. This is too easy!

I'd love to see at least TWO posts where I directly said that I loved dogs and/or hated cats.

[Phaelyn]

Jan 10, 2011 11:29:36 GMT -8 @tercielsilvi said:

Here are the facts we have so far:

• There are 26 people left in the village. Five of these are mafia, meaning that there is a 19% chance that a random lynch would be beneficial for the village.
  
• No-one has claimed to be the detective, this is most likely because their investigation turned up a villager, and it is not yet advantageous for the mafia to claim to be so.
  
• Because of this, it really is a case of just choosing a person at random. I am inclined not to vote Robert because he got killed first in all the previous games, and we really have no leads.
  

As I was detective last game, I figured I'd address this

The detective would be stupid to come out in this stage of the game. My first guesses were villagers, yes, but I guessed correctly for Ricky, HP, and Woop (with the investigations, that is). However, I'd already contacted Patrick and Ryan and this stage (one on a hunch, one on an investigation), so they took the bullets for me while while we worked out the other mobsters.

If the Detective came up with a guess, I'd imagine they'd very, very subtly be pushing their findings forward. So far, I haven't seen any of that yet, though, so I'm doubting the detective's found a mobster yet.

edit;; I'm not sure if Adam's joking or not. My vote sort of depends on that at the moment

Also, the comment on my sig -- Jetta drew my avatar cause she made everyone else dogs, and then my friend worked off that to make my sig for a birthday present (note the bottom right corner) i do love dogs, but that doesn't mean i hate cats <3

[Ryan Roos]

Jan 10, 2011 11:33:40 GMT -8 Andrea said:

You forget that we know Crow is the mayor as well, so 25 villagers are left, 5 of which are in the mafia.

CLARIFICATION : The Mayor is a secondary role. Anyone with any position including mafia could be the Mayor. The mayor was randomly selected to start and all future mayors are chosen by their predecessor.

[tercielsilvi]

Jan 10, 2011 11:33:40 GMT -8 Andrea said:

Jan 10, 2011 11:29:36 GMT -8 @tercielsilvi said:

Here are the facts we have so far:

• There are 26 people left in the village. Five of these are mafia, meaning that there is a 19% chance that a random lynch would be beneficial for the village.
  
• No-one has claimed to be the detective, this is most likely because their investigation turned up a villager, and it is not yet advantageous for the mafia to claim to be so.
  
• Because of this, it really is a case of just choosing a person at random. I am inclined not to vote Robert because he got killed first in all the previous games, and we really have no leads.
  

You forget that we know Crow is the mayor as well, so 25 villagers are left, 5 of which are in the mafia.

It doesn't say anywhere in the role description that the mayor has to be a villager. The mafia are in disguise, remember?

[Andrea]

Jan 10, 2011 11:39:54 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Jan 10, 2011 11:33:40 GMT -8 Andrea said:

You forget that we know Crow is the mayor as well, so 25 villagers are left, 5 of which are in the mafia.

CLARIFICATION : The Mayor is a secondary role. Anyone with any position including mafia could be the Mayor. The mayor was randomly selected to start and all future mayors are chosen by their predecessor.

Thank you for the clarification!

Hmm. Phaelyn makes a good point as well.

[Ara (Crow)]

If you really think about it Baggy has been a large scale player in the past, she's backed up her claims and we can all agree that her role was major in the first game's outcome. Meaning: whoever are in the mafia chose her on purpose to cause whatever confusion they could, meaning they also have to had played the fist round. Considering if that idea is true or not.

[Adam]

Jan 10, 2011 11:39:52 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Also, the comment on my sig -- Jetta drew my avatar cause she made everyone else dogs, and then my friend worked off that to make my sig for a birthday present (note the bottom right corner) i do love dogs, but that doesn't mean i hate cats <3

Aha! Without realizing it, you have revealed who your boss is!

"Jetta drew my avatar cause she made everyone else dogs..."

Jetta made everyone else dogs. Jetta is the mastermind. Game over.

Good playing everyone, sorry it ended so quickly. Can I host the next one?