ProBoards Mafia 3 : TMM (Post-Game)

[Trill]

Jan 13, 2011 10:55:11 GMT -8 Robyn said:

Nightwalker told me he knew who would be mafia if it wasn't Aether and I am still interested in knowing who he thinks is it and why.

In this game, nobody knows anything. I believe Nightwalker said last round, with flawed logic, that if Aether isn't mafia, then I am. I already posted multiple reasons why this is a very flawed statement, such as me defending Aether and note voting for him until half way through the votes, only to save myself.

[Pats Freak 101]

I stand by my logic. With Phaelyn's promise to kill herself if Trill is innocent we stand a chance to get rid of both our top suspects.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Jan 13, 2011 10:54:56 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Also, guys? If I can just put this out there, I think we're all skimming through each others' posts way too quickly we might come to a better conclusion if we take a bit to read everything? not trying to be a jerk, just a suggestion xD

Like I said, you'd be wasting your vote to kill me. Think about it: even if you voted for me today, I'm the village elder. You'd have to try again, at which point you'd find out I'm a villager. If you kill Trill and he's a villager, I'll commit suicide and you'll at least save a day of voting.

Ryan can she commit suicide? If so, that makes my job a whole lot easier

[iCraft]

Trill why do you keep saying stuff your making yourself look bad, Just stop posting for a little and let people talk i know you want to defend your self.

[Trill]

Jan 13, 2011 10:58:07 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Trill, I love how you're avoiding every post I've made, yet continue to make the same accusations against me

I don't associate with mafia members.

Your last post, by the way, was not targeted towards me, it was more like a general statement to everyone. If you'd like, I can quote and comment on every single post you make from now on, but I think some people are annoyed of the page length of this thread already.

[Phaelyn]

Jan 13, 2011 10:54:56 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Also, guys? If I can just put this out there, I think we're all skimming through each others' posts way too quickly we might come to a better conclusion if we take a bit to read everything? not trying to be a jerk, just a suggestion xD

Like I said, you'd be wasting your vote to kill me. Think about it: even if you voted for me today, I'm the village elder. You'd have to try again, at which point you'd find out I'm a villager. If you kill Trill and he's a villager, I'll commit suicide and you'll at least save a day of voting.

We should all totally read this.

Jan 13, 2011 11:00:43 GMT -8 Trill said:

Jan 13, 2011 10:58:07 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Trill, I love how you're avoiding every post I've made, yet continue to make the same accusations against me

I don't associate with mafia members.

Your last post, by the way, was not targeted towards me, it was more like a general statement to everyone. If you'd like, I can quote and comment on every single post you make from now on, but I think some people are annoyed of the page length of this thread already.

Mm, if you REALLY believed that I was a mafia member, why would you have even said who the doctor is? Now YOU, sir, deserve the roll eyes smiley xD

[Trill]

Jan 13, 2011 11:00:52 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Jan 13, 2011 10:54:56 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Also, guys? If I can just put this out there, I think we're all skimming through each others' posts way too quickly we might come to a better conclusion if we take a bit to read everything? not trying to be a jerk, just a suggestion xD

Like I said, you'd be wasting your vote to kill me. Think about it: even if you voted for me today, I'm the village elder. You'd have to try again, at which point you'd find out I'm a villager. If you kill Trill and he's a villager, I'll commit suicide and you'll at least save a day of voting.

We should all totally read this.

Jan 13, 2011 10:59:43 GMT -8 Pats Freak 101 said:

I stand by my logic. With Phaelyn's promise to kill herself if Trill is innocent we stand a chance to get rid of both our top suspects.

Do you really think she'd kill herself. And if it turns out she's a mafia member, which I'm 99.999% sure, she wouldn't kill herself. The condition contradicts the outcome. Another example of flawed logic.

PLUS, if Phaelyn's a mafia member, it'll take one vote to get her out anyway. Thus, her whole scenario is inherently flawed.

[Phaelyn]

Jan 13, 2011 11:01:37 GMT -8 Trill said:

Jan 13, 2011 10:59:43 GMT -8 Pats Freak 101 said:

I stand by my logic. With Phaelyn's promise to kill herself if Trill is innocent we stand a chance to get rid of both our top suspects.

Do you really think she'd kill herself. And if it turns out she's a mafia member, which I'm 99.999% sure, she wouldn't kill herself. Another example of flawed logic.

No, I'll definitely do it. 2 1/2 rounds into this game and I haven't broken my word yet.

[Ryan Roos]

CLARIFICATION : Suicide will essentially let you quit the game. All normal death rules apply. If it occurs on a day where someone has already just been lynched or at night then the suicide is a second death for that time frame. If no vote has been reached during the day or the mafia choose the same target as the suicide it counts the normal way. ie) someone committing suicide right now would be today's lynching.

[Phaelyn]

Jan 13, 2011 11:04:08 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

CLARIFICATION : Suicide will essentially let you quit the game. All normal death rules apply. If it occurs on a day where someone has already just been lynched or at night then the suicide is a second death for that time frame. If no vote has been reached during the day or the mafia choose the same target as the suicide it counts the normal way. ie) someone committing suicide right now would be today's lynching.

So commiting suicide would not affect the villagers' daily lynchings, if I read this correctly?

Also, another thing, guys: If I didn't hold to my word, I think it would be preeetty obvious who's mafia, huh?

[Ace Trainer Dom]

So I guess that means if we lynch Trill today and he's innocent, Phaelyn you can then immediately commit suicide

Not the most ideal if you are both innocent to be honest...

[CheatAreZee]

I'll switch my vote back to Trill then. You lot are starting to hurt my head

[Phaelyn]

Jan 13, 2011 11:06:42 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

So I guess that means if we lynch Trill today and he's innocent, Phaelyn you can then immediately commit suicide

Not the most ideal if you are both innocent to be honest...

I'm pretty sure the cheating with the PMs pretty much means he's mafia, truth be told I don't see any reason for a villager to do that.


by the way, trill, i hope you're not taking any of this personally. it's all just the game <3

[Trill]

Jan 13, 2011 11:06:42 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

So I guess that means if we lynch Trill today and he's innocent, Phaelyn you can then immediately commit suicide

Not the most ideal if you are both innocent to be honest...

How does that make sense? She won't commit suicide after you lynch be. See my previous post. It's all conditional on the fact if she is or isn't mafia, which negates her threat of suicide and the 2-vote requirement for her supposed role of village elder.

[Phaelyn]

Jan 13, 2011 11:08:36 GMT -8 Trill said:

Jan 13, 2011 11:06:42 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

So I guess that means if we lynch Trill today and he's innocent, Phaelyn you can then immediately commit suicide

Not the most ideal if you are both innocent to be honest...

How does that make sense? She won't commit suicide after you lynch be. See my previous post. It's all conditional on the fact if she is or isn't mafia, which negates her threat of suicide and the 2-vote requirement for her supposed role of village elder.

If i'm lying about being the village elder and am actually mafia, it wouldn't exactly be hard to kill me, would it

also, again, ignoring what I said on suicide a couple posts ago.