ProBoards Mafia 3 : TMM (Post-Game)

[Adam]

Jan 10, 2011 12:21:15 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Okay, before I vote for Adam, I'll ask him:

Were you joking, or were you just totally grasping at straws?

lol

I'm joking of course. I'm actually quite thrilled that Robert has taken me seriously. In all other threads where I've had serious posts directed to him he has ignored me. I challenge his religion and I get no response. I challenge his love for cats and he's all over me!

In all seriousness, we aren't going to have any sort of real evidence toward anyone.

The best idea so far is offing those who knew Bagheera's play style from before, but honestly, I don't think that is fair.

If we are going to start choosing people at random, then we might as well just start from the top of the player list and go down.

[Robyn]

Jan 10, 2011 12:24:08 GMT -8 Matej said:

I hate the first round; it's pretty much a guaranteed villager kill.

That said though, I doubt it's Adam being mafia.
Robert might be, based on the defense he has posted so far, but that's also too little to decide...
I'll wait before a final vote.

Now to be honest, go ahead and vote for whomever. But read what Adam posted about me hating cats and stuff. Do you seriously think I would randomly PM an admin about that?

Plus Adam has yet to answer my question...

Jan 10, 2011 12:29:38 GMT -8 Adam said:

Jan 10, 2011 12:21:15 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Okay, before I vote for Adam, I'll ask him:

Were you joking, or were you just totally grasping at straws?

lol

I'm joking of course. I'm actually quite thrilled that Robert has taken me seriously. In all other threads where I've had serious posts directed to him he has ignored me. I challenge his religion and I get no response. I challenge his love for cats and he's all over me!

In all seriousness, we aren't going to have any sort of real evidence toward anyone.

The best idea so far is offing those who knew Bagheera's play style from before, but honestly, I don't think that is fair.

If we are going to start choosing people at random, then we might as well just start from the top of the player list and go down.

Well duh I'm going to correct you on your whole story on me hating cats. It's incorrect!

Religion is different, because you have to have faith in what you believe. Of course I didn't answer Adam's questions because usually when I get wired up with debates like that, I tend to ignore many posts that are simply asking "why? why? why?"

And besides, if I was mafia I would be accusing random members of stuff. Kind of like Adam, joking or not. Think about it. If you were mafia, either you don't post at all, or you pull a Ryan and post with tons of proof of this and that.

I have no proof that anyone is Mafia. No one really does until the next round.

And I just realized that Adam is trying to compare my lack of responses to my religion debates vs some random thing about cats. Religion is personal, if you're religious you know that. The way this game works is to defend yourself, no matter what position you are. So if someone claimed some random thing about me that wasn't true, of course I'm going to defend it and say they're wrong, because they are.

Plus I would probably suck being Mafia, I'm not really good at the whole accusing thing.

[tercielsilvi]

I think I'm just going to jump on the Adam bandwagon. We really have no idea who to vote for, and there's a small group of people who've already voted for him. In order to progress the game, let's just kill Adam.

[Dove]

I think I will go with Capitan. There's really no way to know for sure. I'm sorry Adam, if you aren't mafia.

My vote is for Adam.

[Adam]

Jan 10, 2011 12:31:54 GMT -8 Robyn said:

And besides, if I was mafia I would be accusing random members of stuff. Kind of like Adam, joking or not. Think about it. If you were mafia, either you don't post at all, or you pull a Ryan and post with tons of proof of this and that.

Haha, I'm just having fun. Notice how I haven't actually accused anyone of being mafia... I only accused Robert of choking cats, and possibly of being a witch, but nothing more. Everyone else I've only accused of being cat haters.

[CheatAreZee]

Even though I think I would enjoy reading his future posts in this thread, I'll also jump on the Adam vote.

[Adam]

I change my vote from Robert to Ren since she is at the top of the player list. I would prefer to keep lynchings orderly until we have actual evidence.

[Ren Rudner]

Sorry Adam...

Adam

Edit: wait, I'm not sorry! You voted for me jerk!

[Phaelyn]

I'll go Adam, if just to move things along a bit sorry.

[Robyn]

Jan 10, 2011 12:44:44 GMT -8 Adam said:

Jan 10, 2011 12:31:54 GMT -8 Robyn said:

And besides, if I was mafia I would be accusing random members of stuff. Kind of like Adam, joking or not. Think about it. If you were mafia, either you don't post at all, or you pull a Ryan and post with tons of proof of this and that.

Haha, I'm just having fun. Notice how I haven't actually accused anyone of being mafia... I only accused Robert of choking cats, and possibly of being a witch, but nothing more. Everyone else I've only accused of being cat haters.

Ah well having fun is different. But your vote to me was based on the story, which was already proven to be not be relevant to anyone or their positions. And surviving the first round was pretty nice of the mafia, so I was a bit upset to see everyone pointing at me. Which is why I did what you should do, defend yourself. If I get the chance to be mafia, of course I'll do a better job.

[iCraft]

We need 8 more Votes to knock of adam

[Trill]

I'm just popping into this thread quickly. In the sign up thread I mentioned ahead of time that I won't be online tonight until very late, if at all. So don't accuse me of being a mafia member just because I'm quickly jumping on the bandwagon without any meaningfull posts, haha. I'll go with the majority for now, just to get my vote in before I have to leave. Adam

[Andrea]

There's no evidence against Adam, but then again there's no evidence against anyone at this time. So, to keep the game moving forward, I am going to place my vote for Adam.

[Adam]

Jan 10, 2011 12:49:32 GMT -8 Robyn said:

Ah well having fun is different. But your vote to me was based on the story, which was already proven to be not be relevant to anyone or their positions. And surviving the first round was pretty nice of the mafia, so I was a bit upset to see everyone pointing at me. Which is why I did what you should do, defend yourself. If I get the chance to be mafia, of course I'll do a better job.

Allow me to defend myself. I'm not mafia and lynching me would be a mistake.

I recommend starting from the top of the list for lynchings and being suspect of those who voted for me first.

Let's not rely on random stabs in the dark or whoever posts the most gets the first wack. Let's keep things orderly.

[Søren]

Think I vote Adam to