ProBoards Mafia 3 : TMM (Post-Game)

[tercielsilvi]

Jan 10, 2011 12:55:11 GMT -8 Adam said:

Jan 10, 2011 12:49:32 GMT -8 Robyn said:

Ah well having fun is different. But your vote to me was based on the story, which was already proven to be not be relevant to anyone or their positions. And surviving the first round was pretty nice of the mafia, so I was a bit upset to see everyone pointing at me. Which is why I did what you should do, defend yourself. If I get the chance to be mafia, of course I'll do a better job.

Allow me to defend myself. I'm not mafia and lynching me would be a mistake.

I recommend starting from the top of the list for lynchings and being suspect of those who voted for me first.

Let's not rely on random stabs in the dark or whoever posts the most gets the first wack. Let's keep things orderly.

You come first alphabetically!

[Adam]

I promise I'm not mafia. You don't want to kill me.

[Dove]

Why not? If it could save your life today, then I'd recommend telling us why...

I'm still convinced though. You haven't really stood up for yourself much.

[Andrea]

I'm retracting my vote for Adam. I have a small feeling that he isn't in the mafia.

[Phaelyn]

Retracting my vote. If you guys wanna kill him, go ahead, but either way, I'd rather not have blood on my hands quite yet...I just don't know who's who at this point, y'know?

[iCraft]

This is Hard im going to stay in the back of the pack also I RETRACT MY VOTE the least i can do is let Adam protect him self.

[VS Admin]

The fact is no one knows who is mafia today. This day just needs to be gotten through. Keep piling the votes on Adam and lets get to day 2 where the detective can get more done.

edit: And wouldn't it be funny if mafia voted for their fellow brother, Adam, and then just retracted their votes........... hmmm!!!

[Adam]

Jan 10, 2011 12:59:37 GMT -8 Dove said:

Why not? If it could save your life today, then I'd recommend telling us why...

I'm still convinced though. You haven't really stood up for yourself much.

Please re-read all my posts where I say I'm not mafia.

Plus, I love cats. Bagheera would be very upset at how you've changed from the first game Dove.

[Trill]

Maybe we should take a little bit of time to think this through. When I voted I hadn't realized we were this close to a majority. Adam is saying that he's a player we don't want to lose, implying that he's has an important role to the villagers. Now if we don't vote for him, and the mafia doesn't kill him, that means he might be part of the mafia. The mafia would probably want to kill him tonight anyway, knowing that he supposedly has a vital role. I don't know if another majority can be reached in time, but I'm leaving my vote for Adam at the moment.

edit: that was fast. Everyone retracting their votes at the same time? Well we know that they aren't all the mafia because that would be a horrible strategy to give up their alliance this quickly

[Thesealion]

Ok since we seem to have decided we will kill someone i will look this over.

1. My first guess would not have been Robert. Could the mafia be trying to get us to off him because of the first few games or are they trying get us to do the opposite?
2. I don't think both Adam and Robert are mafia since why would they give themselves up on the first turn?
3. With all this info and what i have read i really don't see any reason to vote for Robert. Adam did jump on Robert and even though he says it was a joke it might be that he is trying to save himself...

I am going NO LYNCH right now. I will not vote for Robert and Adam will be my vote if nothing else comes up in the next few hours.

[Phaelyn]

Okay, once and for all, I'll vote for Adam. Again, sorry, but there's no evidence for or against anyone at this point...Pat's right

[Dove]

... I know.... I need to survive for her honor and dignity!

Retracting my vote for Adam

...because of an inkling.

[Former Member]

Think calmly guys, why not do a no lynch? If we do so, then we might be able to think things through carefully and see who gets killed next. this way our verdicts will be more orderly rather than all over the place. Hoorah for the Neighbourhood Watch!

No Lynch!

[Andrea]

Jan 10, 2011 13:03:47 GMT -8 Trill said:

Maybe we should take a little bit of time to think this through. When I voted I hadn't realized we were this close to a majority. Adam is saying that he's a player we don't want to lose, implying that he's has an important role to the villagers. Now if we don't vote for him, and the mafia doesn't kill him, that means he might be part of the mafia. The mafia would probably want to kill him tonight anyway, knowing that he supposedly has a vital role. I don't know if another majority can be reached in time, but I'm leaving my vote for Adam at the moment.

And if Adam is in the mafia, then he most likely will not be killed tonight, which means if he survives to tomorrow, then at least we can make small assumptions that maybe he actually is in the mafia. At least in this case we'll have a small bit of evidence to back up our vote against Adam. That is, unless the mafia is willing to sacrifice one of their own tonight.

[Robyn]

Adam has PMed me. To be honest I can never tell when people are being serious, hence why I'm almost glad I was killed the last two rounds. I learned how everyone defends themselves.

I know that we have to vote for someone. Adam PMed me trying to convince me of who he says he really is. Adam is suddenly being very serious, but then again who wouldn't? He hasn't really said much since then...