ProBoards Mafia 3 : TMM (Post-Game)

[Matej]

I'm going to go on a hunch, but the fact Robert is still alive and the mafia doesn't touch him, might also be a clue to everyone.
He also seems slightly oblivious to some facts, possibly intentionally (pretending) to do so.

So for now, I'll actually immediately cast a vote for Robert.

It's a hunch, but better than what I've seen so far.
Might change it later though.

[tercielsilvi]

I'm fairly certain that Phaelyn is in the clean [of course, I keep saying that about people ]. Re: Adam, that was Day 1 which we can now pretty much disregard.

I think we should wait and see who else posts before we do anything rash. Maaaan this is like Day 1 all over again.

[Phaelyn]

I know, Capitan D:

and guys, I'll reiterate: I'm not mafia. I would NOT have spent pretty much the entire day bickering with trill and trying to convince the rest of you to believe me just to gain your trust. If I were mafia, it would've been a LOT easier just to pick a random one of you and start voting. And again, I'm a villager with the village elder thing, so yeah. Lynching me is a waste.

I have no leads at the moment; sorry, guys.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Jan 13, 2011 18:53:29 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

I know, Capitan D:

and guys, I'll reiterate: I'm not mafia. I would NOT have spent pretty much the entire day bickering with trill and trying to convince the rest of you to believe me just to gain your trust. If I were mafia, it would've been a LOT easier just to pick a random one of you and start voting. And again, I'm a villager with the village elder thing, so yeah. Lynching me is a waste.

I have no leads at the moment; sorry, guys.

lol that doesn't mean I can't include you on my suspect list.

[Phaelyn]

Jan 13, 2011 18:57:37 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Jan 13, 2011 18:53:29 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

I know, Capitan D:

and guys, I'll reiterate: I'm not mafia. I would NOT have spent pretty much the entire day bickering with trill and trying to convince the rest of you to believe me just to gain your trust. If I were mafia, it would've been a LOT easier just to pick a random one of you and start voting. And again, I'm a villager with the village elder thing, so yeah. Lynching me is a waste.

I have no leads at the moment; sorry, guys.

lol that doesn't mean I can't include you on my suspect list.

If it comes down to a lynch on me, I'll happily commit suicide so you guys have two more days of lynchings to get real mafia members. No, I'm not bluffing.

[CheatAreZee]

Jan 13, 2011 18:46:48 GMT -8 Matej said:

I'm going to go on a hunch, but the fact Robert is still alive and the mafia doesn't touch him, might also be a clue to everyone.
He also seems slightly oblivious to some facts, possibly intentionally (pretending) to do so.

So for now, I'll actually immediately cast a vote for Robert.

It's a hunch, but better than what I've seen so far.
Might change it later though.

I think if we get desperate enough, I might work with this theory. Won't lock in a vote just yet though.

One user that is stands out to me, and has been brought up, would be fuzzy. While I know they have stated reasons for not being around much, at this point, I think it would worth giving them the axe. They haven't provided much input at all in the game thus far. The only thing I can really remember from them was defending Ren at first, but one thing I have to give them is that they voted for Ren in the end (though that could have been done because Ren was a sinking ship at that point). Other than that, I can't recall many other posts here.

[iCraft]

Wb we look at the people who didnt vote for Ren and then go from there its just an idea

[tercielsilvi]

Jan 13, 2011 19:23:13 GMT -8 iCraft said:

Wb we look at the people who didnt vote for Ren and then go from there its just an idea

You will find me in that list, because I was asleep for that whole (in-game) day. You will also find that I'm going to sleep now as it is 3.30am, so if this day concludes and I haven't voted, that is why.

ed; I'll uninvisible my profile, too :X

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Here's the way I see it. This round is all about deception. Trill was a smart leader of the mafia, so here's what I think: Every mafia member is playing a different role. One's hanging back not saying much, One (Trill) was posting actively trying to swing the vote. One probably has a secondary role (I am a bit curious as to why Crow hasn't been killed by the mafia yet). One probably won't be voting for the mafia members until last, and one may be introducing the names of mafia members in order to build trust. My point is, Trill played this game smart, it took a lot of work to catch him in a lie, and ultimately we weren't entirely sure until the news article came out. And because he played smart, he probably left orders for the rest of the mafia that will ensure they weasel their way into our trust zone. I therefore want to remind everyone to NOT trust anyone you are in an alliance with. I was in an Alliance with Andrea, who not once told me she was the doctor. In fact, it wasn't until she was killed that I learned who she was, and not by her, but by Trill in a PM, trying to use the same screenshots that were disproven later in the daytime to get me to vote Phaelyn. My point is anyone can be a suspect, so don't rule anyone out, not until the last mafia member is gone. Don't just look for motives, try and see it from the view of the Godfather trying to succeed in integrating the mafia into the villagers, because without a detective, trust is everything to the mafia in this game.

Think about Phaelyn's post. She is hiding behind the elder status as a shield, hoping that if we do take the opportunity to lynch her, her status as an elder will prove her story. However, that only proves her secondary role and I only see two possible scenarios. One, she is a villager and once the vote nears a majority she will commit suicide revealing the truth of her villager heritage. Or two, she doesn't commit suicide, meaning she's hiding something and we need to lynch her to make sure she isn't mafia. It's simple, what she's posting seems to be all about her concern for the well-being of the village, but that's also a post to gain the trust of everyone here, or at least enough to sway votes in the mafia's favor.


I will end saying this. If I am to die at any point, heed my observations please, I am doing my best to try and see this from the Godfather's viewpoint so as to find out who is mafia, and it is likely that if I start getting too many accusations right I will be murdered. Or you can all lynch me first, and then follow what I observed when I die. Phaelyn is continually saying how she wants to not waste a lynching for the village, but now she is becoming defensive and not trying to find a more suspicious person to lynch. This is the opposite of what the godfather was doing, in fact everything she has done has been the opposite of what the godfather did. That is too much of a coincidence for it to not be planned .


That's about all I have

[iCraft]

Jan 13, 2011 19:28:26 GMT -8 @tercielsilvi said:

Jan 13, 2011 19:23:13 GMT -8 iCraft said:

Wb we look at the people who didnt vote for Ren and then go from there its just an idea

You will find me in that list, because I was asleep for that whole (in-game) day. You will also find that I'm going to sleep now as it is 3.30am, so if this day concludes and I haven't voted, that is why.

ed; I'll uninvisible my profile, too :X

I understand this i say cross out the people who have a good reason why they where not on

[Phaelyn]

Ah, I'm done with this. I'll save you guys time and save me a ton of insanity

I've committed suicide in some manner involving self-inflicted crowbar wounds. Sorry to those that doubted me, but I've grown tired of constantly having to defend myself when I've proven my worth in every way. All I can let you know is that I've been entirely truthful this whole time.

(this isn't me being a quitter, this is me (1) saving my finals grade and (2) saving you all quite a bit of time. i'm bored of fighting everyone off when i've done everything right, and it's frustrating as hell. so yeah. xD good luck guys. see you all next game!)

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Edit: ^umm...yay? Either I just saw right through the mafia or I am going to be lynched tomorrow

Btw, Just in case, as this has happened already: My only contact with people about this game in PMs was between those that are dead now (Specifically Aether, Andrea, and Trill) If anyone comes out and tries to say they were in a PM convo with me here at support, and you guys go against me, When I am proven to be a villager I beg you to lynch whoever brings that information up, as they will be mafia.

Edit: fixed Andrea's name

[iCraft]

Phaelyn dont do that

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Jan 13, 2011 19:52:16 GMT -8 iCraft said:

Phaelyn dont do that

It's already done, I don't think there's any going back now

[Phaelyn]

Why not, iCraft? I'm of more use to the village dead than alive with me dead, they're no longer wondering if I'm mafia, they won't be spending two in-game days voting for me, just to find I'm a villager. This way, they'll focus on the mafia and I won't have to fend off accusations anymore. The last game day was really, really taxing and I don't feel like doing that again. xD Not this round, anyway.