ProBoards Mafia 3 : TMM (Post-Game)

[Andrea]

Jan 13, 2011 19:44:48 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Edit: ^umm...yay? Either I just saw right through the mafia or I am going to be lynched tomorrow

Btw, Just in case, as this has happened already: My only contact with people about this game in PMs was between those that are dead now (Specifically Aether, Angela, and Trill) If anyone comes out and tries to say they were in a PM convo with me here at support, and you guys go against me, When I am proven to be a villager I beg you to lynch whoever brings that information up, as they will be mafia.

-cough- just posting to edit that Angela = Andrea

[★Fuzzy★]

Jan 13, 2011 19:18:00 GMT -8 CheatAreZee said:

Jan 13, 2011 18:46:48 GMT -8 Matej said:

I'm going to go on a hunch, but the fact Robert is still alive and the mafia doesn't touch him, might also be a clue to everyone.
He also seems slightly oblivious to some facts, possibly intentionally (pretending) to do so.

So for now, I'll actually immediately cast a vote for Robert.

It's a hunch, but better than what I've seen so far.
Might change it later though.

I think if we get desperate enough, I might work with this theory. Won't lock in a vote just yet though.

One user that is stands out to me, and has been brought up, would be fuzzy. While I know they have stated reasons for not being around much, at this point, I think it would worth giving them the axe. They haven't provided much input at all in the game thus far. The only thing I can really remember from them was defending Ren at first, but one thing I have to give them is that they voted for Ren in the end (though that could have been done because Ren was a sinking ship at that point). Other than that, I can't recall many other posts here.

Sorry, but my reasons were true. I went to sleep, went to school, and I come home and there is 20 pages for me to read. It makes it kind of hard when you have many things to do. And don't say "well don't sign up if you are going to be inactive". I come on everyday. I come on to see 20 pages that I don't want to stare at all day, and I admin my own board, and am staff on another board.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Jan 13, 2011 20:42:45 GMT -8 Andrea said:

Jan 13, 2011 19:44:48 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Edit: ^umm...yay? Either I just saw right through the mafia or I am going to be lynched tomorrow

Btw, Just in case, as this has happened already: My only contact with people about this game in PMs was between those that are dead now (Specifically Aether, Angela, and Trill) If anyone comes out and tries to say they were in a PM convo with me here at support, and you guys go against me, When I am proven to be a villager I beg you to lynch whoever brings that information up, as they will be mafia.

-cough- just posting to edit that Angela = Andrea

I'm sorry, it was on my cell phone and apparently it prefers Angela over Andrea. Blame Swype

[Andrea]

Jan 13, 2011 21:48:36 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Jan 13, 2011 20:42:45 GMT -8 Andrea said:

-cough- just posting to edit that Angela = Andrea

I'm sorry, it was on my cell phone and apparently it prefers Angela over Andrea. Blame Swype

it's all good. *returns to the grave*

[Ace Trainer Dom]

I'm glad that's over, I don't need any enemies from beyond the grave

[**hp]

Jan 13, 2011 17:08:11 GMT -8 iCraft said:

Crow but she has a reason

It's easy to say there's a reason, but as we've seen thus far, the game has been thoroughly covered with deception. Twice, Crow has posted and then the mafia has struck immediately after. Crow shows the lack of involvement in lynch discussions that a mafia member would show. Why we aren't paying more attention to Crow is a bit confusing to me...

[Ace Trainer Dom]

I thought since Phaelyn committed suicide it's night time but I guess Ryan will have to confirm...

[Phaelyn]

This is a somewhat morbid game, come to think of it...

[Ara (Crow)]

Jan 13, 2011 22:18:10 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

This is a somewhat morbid game, come to think of it...

You just figured that out? ;P

[Robyn]

What? I go to bed and come back the next morning to see some of you voting for me?

So I know it is VERY suspicious, and I will seriously admit that I might have voted for myself by this point. Obviously I'm not going to, only because I know I'm not mafia. It's their way to make me look like mafia.

I've been trying to help now so that we can win the game. Please trust me, ask Nightwalker.

[Matej]

Jan 14, 2011 3:22:44 GMT -8 Robyn said:

What? I go to bed and come back the next morning to see some of you voting for me?

So I know it is VERY suspicious, and I will seriously admit that I might have voted for myself by this point. Obviously I'm not going to, only because I know I'm not mafia. It's their way to make me look like mafia.

I've been trying to help now so that we can win the game. Please trust me, ask Nightwalker.

Sounds like trying to escape the blame!

I'm sorry Robert, but this post just reinforced my vote for you.

[Robyn]

But what makes me so suspicious? Unlike the other mafia members who pretty much tried to get video of their computer screens, I'm fully willing to let you guys vote for me. It's your choice. It's been fun being the villager for these many days and nights. I've enjoyed helping out and lynching people (even if they were innocent ) so go ahead. I have nothing to argue about. It's just a fun game.

To be honest, though, do we have any real evidence against ANYONE?

[Matej]

To be fair, there's no evidence for anyone really.
That's why I said I'm going on a hunch (and pretty ridiculous reasoning) but it's better than nothing.

[Robyn]

Yes, I know we have nothing. But as I was saying in a few pages ago, we should just start voting against those who don't post much and see if they react like Trill did. Unless of course the good guys don't post much. Of course my way of thinking may be completely wrong.

[Thesealion]

I will vouch for Robert.

I am not absolutely positive but i haven't seen anything against him and i have had extensive conversations with him. I wasn't able to get online yesterday so would someone mind summing up the last 40 or so pages?

Edit: OK i see we got the Godfather. I suspect **hp but the only reason for this is because **hp agreed with Trill a lot. I don't have another suspect ATM...

Edit 2: PHAELYN HOW COULD YOU??? I wonder if i had been online to stop her would it have helped

Jan 13, 2011 19:18:00 GMT -8 CheatAreZee said:

Jan 13, 2011 18:46:48 GMT -8 Matej said:

I'm going to go on a hunch, but the fact Robert is still alive and the mafia doesn't touch him, might also be a clue to everyone.
He also seems slightly oblivious to some facts, possibly intentionally (pretending) to do so.

So for now, I'll actually immediately cast a vote for Robert.

It's a hunch, but better than what I've seen so far.
Might change it later though.

I think if we get desperate enough, I might work with this theory. Won't lock in a vote just yet though.

One user that is stands out to me, and has been brought up, would be fuzzy. While I know they have stated reasons for not being around much, at this point, I think it would worth giving them the axe. They haven't provided much input at all in the game thus far. The only thing I can really remember from them was defending Ren at first, but one thing I have to give them is that they voted for Ren in the end (though that could have been done because Ren was a sinking ship at that point). Other than that, I can't recall many other posts here.

Fuzzy has seemed weird too. At first i marked it down as just being busy but maybe you are on to something...