ProBoards Mafia Game 4 (POST-GAME)

[Ara (Crow)]

Well, a predictable attempt at silencing Ryan. So know we know that the mafia want known debaters to be silenced.

[Thesealion]

Looking at login times i think i can narrow it down to two people that i think we were waiting on. I do not however think we were waiting on mafia but i do have a question on that.

Phaelyn if the mafia had all voted but the godfather had not got online would another mafia member be able to send in the vote?

[bagheera]

*wakes up and sends flowers to the hospital* Clever, but at least he may still wake up. (And maybe one game Ryan and I will actually get to work together. Cue 'dynamic duo' music. )

So, any ideas?

I'm pretty much at a blank right now, but I'm going to go calculate the numbers of whether we're better to go for a no lynch at first rather than risk killing the detective again. *goes to see how Syko did that last game*

[Trill]

Nightwalker, I don't think the mafia would have picked a Godfather who wasn't online to accept their role. We can safely assume the mafia decided on someone who accepted the role and was online, and thus would have been able to send in the hit.

[Thesealion]

Jan 23, 2011 8:13:05 GMT -8 Trill said:

Nightwalker, I don't think the mafia would have picked a Godfather who wasn't online to accept their role. We can safely assume the mafia decided on someone who accepted the role and was online, and thus would have been able to send in the hit.

Do the mafia pick the Godfather? I didn't know that...

[Tk]

I'm terrified of dentists :/
That role is too scary for me lol!
Login times could be useful but maybe it was the detective or the doctor who was slow.

[Tk]

Can the mafia kill ryan next turn? Or only when he is out of the coma (out of the safe hospital?)

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Ryan got picked? awww, poor Ryan, he always had humor in his posts

With regards to login times, who are they? I hope they are mafia and not the detective or doctor though

And FINALLY! Somebody actually used the dentist role

EDIT: Wow I forgot how fast posts come and go in the early stages

[Tk]

Yeah - I think we are all tired of waiting, so any ideas anyone?

[Trill]

The inactive person holding up the game was either the Doctor or Detective. Mafia would have sent in the hit regardless if there was a few inactive mafia.

(This is going to put a target on my back already, but...) Last night someone blurted out that he/she was the one the game was waiting on. PM me asking who this was and I'll probably suspect you of being mafia trying to kill Doc/Det.

[Tk]

Jan 23, 2011 8:20:08 GMT -8 Trill said:

The inactive person holding up the game was either the Doctor or Detective. Mafia would have sent in the hit regardless if there was a few inactive mafia.

(This is going to put a target on my back already, but...) Last night someone blurted out that he/she was the one the game was waiting on. PM me asking who this was and I'll probably suspect you of being mafia trying to kill Doc/Det.

I'd just scold them for making me wait!

[Thesealion]

I have two people who didn't log in yesterday or since the game started. They are both invisible but neither of them have posted. This really doesn't say anything yet but if it happens a few more times i will release the names.

[bagheera]

Okay, there's five Mafia and eighteen villagers left, right? That gives us... about a 78% chance, if I'm not mistaken, of hitting a villager. >.<

I'd say we should target inactive players first, but given Trill's reasoning, I think I tentatively support a "no lynch" right now. So for now... no lynch.

[Ara (Crow)]

If we go for no lynch we're giving the mafia another chance at a free kill, and we're putting up the risk of losing another villager, or a high position.

[Thesealion]

I say we should vote for someone. I know what happened last game but i think i know a few people who may be the nurse or detective and i will not vote for a lynch for them.

I say we vote for someone. Give me a name and i will vote...