Mafia! Game 5 (After Party)

[Alex Zechiel]

Feb 11, 2011 14:48:54 GMT -8 Ara (Crow) said:

I seriously have my doubts of having Phaelyn lynched. Think about it, really. So she was the narrator last game, I really fail to see how this would make her any more valuable of a target. Anyone with half a brain knows that just because she was a narrator it doesn't mean anything THIS game. I stick to my vote of Soren.

I've no idea if Phaelyn is mafia, the logic is that so far all the narrators have died right away, so the fact that the last narrator DIDN'T die first in this game is a bit of reason to suspect she's mafia. I honestly don't think there's enough evidence there yet so I'm withholding my vote for a bit, but that's where the logic stems from.

[Phaelyn]

Feb 11, 2011 14:55:26 GMT -8 Alex Zechiel said:

Feb 11, 2011 14:48:54 GMT -8 Ara (Crow) said:

I seriously have my doubts of having Phaelyn lynched. Think about it, really. So she was the narrator last game, I really fail to see how this would make her any more valuable of a target. Anyone with half a brain knows that just because she was a narrator it doesn't mean anything THIS game. I stick to my vote of Soren.

I've no idea if Phaelyn is mafia, the logic is that so far all the narrators have died right away, so the fact that the last narrator DIDN'T die first in this game is a bit of reason to suspect she's mafia. I honestly don't think there's enough evidence there yet so I'm withholding my vote for a bit, but that's where the logic stems from.

Did Aether die at the beginning of the second game? Genuinely wondering, I don't remember.

ed;; just checked, Robert was the first killed for the first two games.

[Adam]

Feb 11, 2011 14:38:43 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

In the other games, they did do stuff on the first night, though?

Aether: did the doctor and detective work on the first night?

I'm not Aether, but I know the answer. Yes, they do. (based on previous games).

Wouldn't be fair to let mafia have a go without Det. and Doc. doing their thing.

[Andrea]

Feb 11, 2011 14:55:58 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Feb 11, 2011 14:55:26 GMT -8 Alex Zechiel said:

I've no idea if Phaelyn is mafia, the logic is that so far all the narrators have died right away, so the fact that the last narrator DIDN'T die first in this game is a bit of reason to suspect she's mafia. I honestly don't think there's enough evidence there yet so I'm withholding my vote for a bit, but that's where the logic stems from.

Did Aether die at the beginning of the second game? Genuinely wondering, I don't remember.

ed;; just checked, Robert was the first killed for the first two games.

I'm mostly talking from experience of the games that I have played. But, I haven't placed a vote yet because like Alex said, there isn't enough sufficient evidence.

[Phaelyn]

Feb 11, 2011 14:59:55 GMT -8 Andrea said:

Feb 11, 2011 14:55:58 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Did Aether die at the beginning of the second game? Genuinely wondering, I don't remember.

ed;; just checked, Robert was the first killed for the first two games.

I'm mostly talking from experience of the games that I have played. But, I haven't placed a vote yet because like Alex said, there isn't enough sufficient evidence.

Dunno -shrug-. Was just trying to clear that up was all, haha.

[Ara (Crow)]

Feb 11, 2011 14:52:52 GMT -8 Andrea said:

Feb 11, 2011 14:48:54 GMT -8 Ara (Crow) said:

I seriously have my doubts of having Phaelyn lynched. Think about it, really. So she was the narrator last game, I really fail to see how this would make her any more valuable of a target. Anyone with half a brain knows that just because she was a narrator it doesn't mean anything THIS game. I stick to my vote of Soren.

The only reason I suggest that as strange is because bagheera was killed during Ryan's game, and Ryan was killed during Phaelyn's game. Ryan and bagheera were narrators. It was merely speculation.

EDIT: I also have no idea where I got the idea that the doctor and detective couldn't do anything on the first night... I just read through again, and am not quite sure. So ignore that haha.

As I siad, what occurred in previous games doesn't matter at all in this game.

[Dove]

Well, as mafia the last two games, I can tell you we purposely kept Robert alive to make him suspicious. Maybe they're doing the same in Phaelyn's case this round? I'm only trying to see from both sides, but I don't think I'm suspicious of Phaelyn. We (as in previous mafia) always debated on pulling something like that off, but we never did because it's ballsy.

I'm currently suspicious of Syko. I had an inkling of both him and Dom at the beginning of the game. Yes, they both voted Patrick, but it's not like that's never happened before, where mafia vote mafia. Dom was very talkative, and now although his last login was 4:52, he's yet to post once. Syko is just a hunch I have.

Not pointing fingers, just discussing.


EDIT: Disregard Dom comments.... XD

[Andrea]

Feb 11, 2011 15:11:01 GMT -8 Ara (Crow) said:

Feb 11, 2011 14:52:52 GMT -8 Andrea said:

The only reason I suggest that as strange is because bagheera was killed during Ryan's game, and Ryan was killed during Phaelyn's game. Ryan and bagheera were narrators. It was merely speculation.

EDIT: I also have no idea where I got the idea that the doctor and detective couldn't do anything on the first night... I just read through again, and am not quite sure. So ignore that haha.

As I siad, what occurred in previous games doesn't matter at all in this game.

And like I said, it's speculation. People were asking for suspicions, so I threw one out there, just like you did with Soren.

Either way... everybody is laying pretty low this game, it seems, so getting suspects is going to be difficult. Patrick, of course, didn't lay low, which made it quite easy to pin him. ;D

[Phaelyn]

Dom's dead, Dove xD but you make a good point with Syko.

[Dove]

...Ohhh... blonde moment...

No offense to blondes o' course.

He just seems to quick to hop on the bandwagon, and he was loud the first two days (like Dom obviously XD ) but now is quiet...

[Phaelyn]

Feb 11, 2011 15:22:33 GMT -8 Dove said:

...Ohhh... blonde moment...

No offense to blondes o' course.

He just seems to quick to hop on the bandwagon, and he was loud the first two days (like Dom obviously XD ) but now is quiet...

If I remember from the mafia game he hosted on 404, he's often gone 8am-8pm EST on some weekdays. Don't quote me on that, but it could be an explanation...maybe.

[Ara (Crow)]

How so very slow this game is going, nothing is happening. Yawn.

[Phaelyn]

Feb 11, 2011 15:24:57 GMT -8 Ara (Crow) said:

How so very slow this game is going, nothing is happening. Yawn.

I know

[Andrea]

Feb 11, 2011 15:24:57 GMT -8 Ara (Crow) said:

How so very slow this game is going, nothing is happening. Yawn.

Unfortunately, your "evidence" against Soren isn't enough to speed it up.

Or anybody's evidence against anybody... this sucks lol.

[Dove]

He seems on fairly often. Last Login for him: 4:37 PM today. But no posts....

It feels like I'm throwing the blame around, but I've got a feeling Capitan and Alex are in hiding too. Maybe not mafia related reasons, but who knows?

Being mafia two games in a row really opens your eyes as a villager.