Mafia! Game 5 (After Party)

[Pepper]

Rest in piece, Girl Dale!

[Girl Dale]

Naw, I'll rest in PIECES.

[Pepper]

Feb 21, 2011 20:26:38 GMT -8 Girl Dale said:

Naw, I'll rest in PIECES.

It's funny because that was the kind of morbid thing that was running through my mind as I typed my previous post. =P

[Trill]

We really need to go back to the list and see who acted oddly in the rounds previous, especially when Ryan and Pat were lynched. Don't make a quick decision, talk it out. As soon as some of us start leaning towards one person, the mafia will hop on board to eliminate another innocent. Let's take our time.

[Phaelyn]

Is Fuzzy even playing still?

[Pepper]

Feb 22, 2011 5:30:45 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Is Fuzzy even playing still?

Yep. He posted on the last page and said he went out of town for the long weekend.

[Andrea]

Alex Zechiel
Jetta
Fuzzy
Trill
Pepper
Phaelyn
Dove
Andrea
Ren Rudner
Adam

These are the alive players, and we have three mafia left...

If we want to go by people asking about whether villagers received a PM, then we can say that Trill, myself, Jetta, and Phaelyn are villagers (as we all made mentions before Aether made a confirmation). That doesn't guarantee anything, of course, just saying.

Alex Zechiel
Fuzzy
Pepper
Dove
Ren Rudner
Adam

EDIT: One thing I noticed about Fuzzy was that he quickly jumped into "sleep" mode when the night phase started, which means that it's likely he was PMed a role, unaware that villagers did not receive a PM. Just an observation.

[Trill]

Aether, were roles assigned randomly via a random number generator?

*has a conspiracy theory about an all-admin Mafia *

[Andrea]

Feb 22, 2011 9:33:21 GMT -8 Trill said:

Aether, were roles assigned randomly via a random number generator?

*has a conspiracy theory about an all-admin Mafia *

I LITERALLY JUST SENT YOU A PM ABOUT THAT!

hahahahahaha.

Well, there's one way to find out. Which of the three admins seems most suspicious? Alex, Adam, or Ren.

[Adam]

Feb 22, 2011 9:33:21 GMT -8 Trill said:

Aether, were roles assigned randomly via a random number generator?

*has a conspiracy theory about an all-admin Mafia *

My favorite part of games like mafia is the randomness of it all. In the first game I played, I was the Detective, and in the second game I got Doctor and Village Elder. I was stoked that I was so lucky to get those roles randomly. I don't like the idea of roles being rigged and I wouldn't willingly play if that were the case. That would just ruin the game for me.

[Pepper]

Feb 22, 2011 9:35:29 GMT -8 Andrea said:

Well, there's one way to find out. Which of the three admins seems most suspicious? Alex, Adam, or Ren.

I'm personally a bit suspicious of Alex because he's been so quiet, and it'd be a good way to stay under the radar. (Note: I haven't looked into his voting patterns or anything. That's just an observation based off of how often I see him posting, and I could easily be forgetting some of his posts.) but randomly voting off an admin would get us nowhere if they're a villager. It'd just dig us into a bigger hole. We shouldn't vote off of conspiracy theories. 'Sides, I don't think Aether would set up the game like that.

[Andrea]

Feb 22, 2011 10:07:47 GMT -8 Pepper said:

Feb 22, 2011 9:35:29 GMT -8 Andrea said:

Well, there's one way to find out. Which of the three admins seems most suspicious? Alex, Adam, or Ren.

I'm personally a bit suspicious of Alex because he's been so quiet, and it'd be a good way to stay under the radar. (Note: I haven't looked into his voting patterns or anything. That's just an observation based off of how often I see him posting, and I could easily be forgetting some of his posts.) but randomly voting off an admin would get us nowhere if they're a villager. It'd just dig us into a bigger hole. We shouldn't vote off of conspiracy theories. 'Sides, I don't think Aether would set up the game like that.

I know.

Which is why my only real accusation was against Fuzzy.

[Phaelyn]

I have a feeling about Adam, though I don't think there's any reason to act on it. He just seems a bit off this game, but nothing I can really pinpoint...

...yeap, that's about all my insight for this round

[Trill]

Feb 22, 2011 10:07:47 GMT -8 Pepper said:

'Sides, I don't think Aether would set up the game like that.

Still, I'd like confirmation just to make sure.

[aether]

---

Feb 22, 2011 9:33:21 GMT -8 Trill said:

Aether, were roles assigned randomly via a random number generator?

*has a conspiracy theory about an all-admin Mafia *

As per the second part of your post, I can't answer that.

All I can say is don't rely on meta-reasoning. That is, don't rely on information that isn't relevant to the in-game dynamics.

---