Reply with another thread, not with a post

[notaro]

Hi everybody,
we need to create a forum where you can reply to a thread with another thread, not with a post.
At the top of the page we need a "Reply List" that shows every single reply to every single thread.
Please, look at this picture (from an italian forum). We have a thread (not shown) and 2 replies. The first reply has a reply itself...
Anyone can add a reply to any post, and so on... and on... and on...

Is it possible?

Here is a link to a thread: forum.alfemminile.com/forum/infidel/__f195868_infidel-Ma-non-vi-vergognate.html#5r

Thanks to anyone will answer... and forgive my bad english writing.

Ciao
Andrew

[Fallen]

support.proboards.com/thread/552188/post-comments This plugin, Post Comments, could come in handy. notaro Hopefully it helps!

[Lynx]

As a note, notaro - it's not advised to post your email. I would suggest editing your post to remove it.

[notaro]

Jul 4, 2016 8:28:32 GMT -8 Lynx said:

As a note, notaro - it's not advised to post your email. I would suggest editing your post to remove it.

Done
Thanks : )

Notaro

[notaro]

Jul 4, 2016 8:19:46 GMT -8 Fallen said:

support.proboards.com/thread/552188/post-comments This plugin, Post Comments, could come in handy. notaro Hopefully it helps!

Thanks for your help and your reply
I already use that plugin, but when someone comments my thread, no one cannot reply it.
I need a plugin that allow to reply with another thread. Every post must have a "reply button" for itself.

Forgive my bad english writing....

Thanks again

Notaro

[Fallen]

Jul 4, 2016 10:04:54 GMT -8 notaro said:

Jul 4, 2016 8:19:46 GMT -8 Fallen said:

support.proboards.com/thread/552188/post-comments This plugin, Post Comments, could come in handy. notaro Hopefully it helps!

Thanks for your help and your reply
I already use that plugin, but when someone comments my thread, no one cannot reply it.
I need a plugin that allow to reply with another thread. Every post must have a "reply button" for itself.

Forgive my bad english writing....

Thanks again

Notaro

I'll tell you if I find anything.

[Todge]

Jul 4, 2016 7:52:45 GMT -8 notaro said:

Hi everybody,
we need to create a forum where you can reply to a thread with another thread, not with a post.
At the top of the page we need a "Reply List" that shows every single reply to every single thread.
Please, look at this picture (from an italian forum). We have a thread (not shown) and 2 replies. The first reply has a reply itself...
Anyone can add a reply to any post, and so on... and on... and on...
View Attachment
Is it possible?

Here is a link to a thread: forum.alfemminile.com/forum/infidel/__f195868_infidel-Ma-non-vi-vergognate.html#5r

Thanks to anyone will answer... and forgive my bad english writing.

Ciao
Andrew

I'm afraid this is not currently possible.

Replying to a post with a thread is not a problem, but displaying each reply on the same page is.

The problem is storage, keys simply are not big enough to hold the contents posts, especially more than one, which would be required to have a reply tree like you have posted. it would even be a problem to list all the replies at the top of the page, for the same reason.

Sorry.

[notaro]

Jul 4, 2016 13:57:20 GMT -8 Fallen said:

Jul 4, 2016 10:04:54 GMT -8 notaro said:

Thanks for your help and your reply
I already use that plugin, but when someone comments my thread, no one cannot reply it.
I need a plugin that allow to reply with another thread. Every post must have a "reply button" for itself.

Forgive my bad english writing....

Thanks again

Notaro

I'll tell you if I find anything.

Thanks again...

Notaro

[notaro]

Jul 4, 2016 16:11:26 GMT -8 Todge said:

Jul 4, 2016 7:52:45 GMT -8 notaro said:

Hi everybody,
we need to create a forum where you can reply to a thread with another thread, not with a post.
At the top of the page we need a "Reply List" that shows every single reply to every single thread.
Please, look at this picture (from an italian forum). We have a thread (not shown) and 2 replies. The first reply has a reply itself...
Anyone can add a reply to any post, and so on... and on... and on...

Is it possible?

Here is a link to a thread: forum.alfemminile.com/forum/infidel/__f195868_infidel-Ma-non-vi-vergognate.html#5r

Thanks to anyone will answer... and forgive my bad english writing.

Ciao
Andrew

I'm afraid this is not currently possible.

Replying to a post with a thread is not a problem, but displaying each reply on the same page is.

The problem is storage, keys simply are not big enough to hold the contents posts, especially more than one, which would be required to have a reply tree like you have posted. it would even be a problem to list all the replies at the top of the page, for the same reason.

Sorry.

Thanks for your help...

Notaro

[Todge]

No worries.. Sorry I couldn't be of more help.

[Boy_Wonder]

Have you tried maybe using the plugin that lets you change post title on each posts? I cannot find it now