Mafia Game (After Party)

[Dumezil]

Oh, good grief. I'd rather ya'll just kill me. We are NEVER going to get to Bagheera or Ryan because ya'll are too stubborn! And I want this game to continue. It is fun to watch.

[Mr. Spartan]

Dec 18, 2010 15:01:16 GMT -8 Dumezil said:

Oh, good grief. I'd rather ya'll just kill me. We are NEVER going to get to Bagheera or Ryan because ya'll are too stubborn! And I want this game to continue. It is fun to watch.

my point exactly

[Thumper]

Dec 18, 2010 15:01:16 GMT -8 Dumezil said:

Oh, good grief. I'd rather ya'll just kill me. We are NEVER going to get to Bagheera or Ryan because ya'll are too stubborn! And I want this game to continue. It is fun to watch.

[bagheera]

Since I don't feel like standing here waiting to be lynched for days more, I'll go with the crowd, then.

Let's lynch Jetta. That, at least, all the villagers should be able to agree upon. If you need more reasoning as to why Jetta's the best choice, PM me.

My vote: Jetta.

[Dove]

I'm still on the fence about Ryan or Bagheera.

Who is voting for Jetta so far? Is it Thumper and Bagheera?

[Syko Nachoman]

So I think I've got this right.

Bagheera votes
iCraft: Bagheera
Jetta: Bagheera
Nightwalker: Bagheera
Ryan: Bagheera
Syko Nachoman: Bagheera

Jetta votes
Bagheera: Ryan
Mr. Spartan: Jetta

Ryan votes
Crow: Ryan
Dove: Ryan
Thumper: Ryan

The problem with voting for Jetta instead of Ryan, as I see it, is that it won't change anything. The people who don't trust bagheera won't have any more reason to believe that Ryan is mafia than Jetta, since all the evidence came from bagheera's posts. Those votes will remain the same. And everyone who does trust bagheera will believe that both are mafia, so the "best" case scenario is that all of those people change their votes to Jetta... and then we're still tied 5-5.

Someone is going to have to change sides (and I don't mean just going from Ryan to Jetta) if we're going to reach a consensus.

[Dove]

Syko, that's 100% true.

I will be standing by Ryan (sorry, dear ) because it won't achieve anything unless, by some miracle, some new evidence is brought forth. Once the next day rolls around, these votes will ALL be the same.

[Mr. Spartan]

I thought Ryan believed Jetta was mafia too?

[Dove]

I'm pretty sure everyone does.

[bagheera]

Everyone does.

This benefits the villagers because...

1. Jetta is voted out. 6 villagers, 3 Mafia.
2a. Villager is killed overnight. 5 villagers, 3 Mafia.
2b. Villager isn't killed overnight. 6 villagers, 3 Mafia. We can now afford to lose a villager.
3. Either way, we've at least killed off one of them. At this point, I should know who the fourth Mafia is, so you can lynch me if you want and as long as the nurse is alive, you might be able to keep the majority.

I mean, I'd love to kill off Ryan and enable us to win this game, but no matter which we go for, it's progress over where we stand right now. Because right now this thread has been dying for days.

[Ara (Crow)]

I leave this thing alone for a few days, and we've yet to come to an agreement, wonder why. I refuse to change my vote, I'm just that stubborn. <3

[Mr. Spartan]

this is going to take forever. Jetta even offered to die!

[aether]

So this doesn't look like it's going somewhere. I'll remind you all of a few things.

First, this is game one. Based on the initial success of this game (not based on the stalemate we find ourselves in now), there may very well be another game.

Second, this game, as well as most other games, has fun built into the progress of the game, and are very much so hindered by stagnation and stubbornness.

Third, the fact that you all agree on one thing yet do something different is very troubling, because I feel as if a political career is in your future.

Fourth, instead of stubbornly holding your position, go back through the thread and look for patterns and hints as to who is really whom. Then, post and provide the evidence. If someone reads your list of (what you feel are) convincing facts and shrugs them off or hardly addresses them at all, perhaps you have reason to consider that person differently.

If anyone feels that I'm overstepping my boundary as the narrator of this game, then maybe they should do something about it that doesn't involve informing me that I'm overstepping my boundary. I feel that part of my job as facilitator is to aide the progress of the game in as neutral a way as I can. That is my logic.

[Ryan Roos]

Wow, I didn't log on all weekend (AGAIN!) and it doesn't look like anything much has happened. I'm sure Bagheera will claim not being on this weekend and nothing happening proves I'm mafia, just like last week when I wasn't on the whole weekend and 2 villagers were murdered meant I was mafia.

Here's your cake, eat it too!

I like Aether's last post. Please, go back through the thread and look for patterns and hints as to who is really whom. ;D

Although I really did expect that I had been double lynched.

[Phaelyn]

Don't mind me, just posting in this thread to shove it back in my most recent topics. I enjoy keeping track of what's going on I can delete this post if you'd like. Plus, game board doesn't +1