GT Mafia: Round 2 ((Post-Game))

[VS Admin]

The "day" started at 6:44am today.

List of people who have not posted yet (more likely to be mafia IMO) along with last login date:

Alex Zechiel (Yesterday at 10:36pm, note: I know he is on a road trip right now so thats sort of an excuse for not posting yet)
Crow (Today at 10:36am) Online after game started with no post
Doves (Yesterday at 5:19am)
Jetta (Yesterday at 5:36pm)
Pats Freak 101 (Yesterday at 6:36pm)
Syko (Today at 5:08am)
woop (Today at 10:46am) Online after game started with no post
ZAR (Today at 9:21am) Online after game started with no post

These are my top suspects just based on the facts.

[aether]

You guys are all acting irrationally. Stop going by the mob mentality! There's reasonably no one who's acting terribly suspicious.

Also, stop having itchy trigger fingers. It's only to the mafia's benefit that we get an accidental majority lynch just because some people felt the need to cast a vote in their first post.

To be honest, I thought Ryan would be the first to go. He is clearly a very intelligent player who has a crazy ability to rationalize/manipulate. Based on this, I have to immediately suspect him, but I won't vote so quickly.

I THINK WE NEED TO CALM DOWN SO THAT WE DON'T MAKE A MISTAKE.

[VS Admin]

Ok, I'm going to switch my vote to someone who has not posted in the thread that has been online since the game started, since I think that is a higher chance to be mafia as they would try to lay low.

My vote is for Crow as they were online less than 30 minutes ago with still no post in this thread. At least this is based on a somewhat rational thought process so we may get lucky on killing a mafia member (see my post 2 up from this one showing online dates of people who have not yet posted). I encourage you to switch your votes.

[Former Member]

Dec 28, 2010 10:54:48 GMT -8 aether said:

You guys are all acting irrationally. Stop going by the mob mentality! There's reasonably no one who's acting terribly suspicious.

Also, stop having itchy trigger fingers. It's only to the mafia's benefit that we get an accidental majority lynch just because some people felt the need to cast a vote in their first post.

To be honest, I thought Ryan would be the first to go. He is clearly a very intelligent player who has a crazy ability to rationalize/manipulate. Based on this, I have to immediately suspect him, but I won't vote so quickly.

I THINK WE NEED TO CALM DOWN SO THAT WE DON'T MAKE A MISTAKE.

It's most likely we'll slip up in this round anyway. So in order to progress we need to knuckle our heads together and think of the most obvious Mafia member so far. The problem is, it's difficult to say. I reckon one of the Admins, or maybe more than one, are Mafia members. This is based on the fact they seem to be fighting over suspicions that they have gained in the real world. In conclusion they all seem to be manipulative, making them a lot more suspicious than any of the others here.

[CheatAreZee]

Dec 28, 2010 10:54:48 GMT -8 aether said:

You guys are all acting irrationally. Stop going by the mob mentality! There's reasonably no one who's acting terribly suspicious.

Also, stop having itchy trigger fingers. It's only to the mafia's benefit that we get an accidental majority lynch just because some people felt the need to cast a vote in their first post.

To be honest, I thought Ryan would be the first to go. He is clearly a very intelligent player who has a crazy ability to rationalize/manipulate. Based on this, I have to immediately suspect him, but I won't vote so quickly.

I THINK WE NEED TO CALM DOWN SO THAT WE DON'T MAKE A MISTAKE.

This is true, actually. After all, what are the chances of Ryan being mafia twice in a row? My main reason for choosing him previously was to retaliate on him for trying to make others suspicious of me. I'll retract my vote for Ryan since it was irrational and not really based on anything.

[Thesealion]

I will keep my vote as it is but i am starting to think that Ryan may not be the admin who is mafia. I will wait a while before making a final decision.

[Ryan Roos]

Pat has given me the most reason to be wary of other people. If Ricky takes his vote of me then I will return the favor as a sign of trust.

I change my vote to Crow.

[Shiraz]

Dec 28, 2010 9:31:23 GMT -8 VS Admin said:

I vote Ricky. I told him I was a villager and asked what he was and he wouldn't say. I can't trust him.

That makes you seem suspicious. =P We're not supposed to tell others what our roles are, anyway, so maybe you were trying to draw him out so you'd know if he was someone worth killing or not.

And just because people have logged in but not posted doesn't mean they're suspicious. They could be reading through the posts to try and figure out who to vote for before they finally post. That's not good enough grounds to lynch someone.

[aether]

Dec 28, 2010 10:59:53 GMT -8 @lostdawn said:

Dec 28, 2010 10:54:48 GMT -8 aether said:

You guys are all acting irrationally. Stop going by the mob mentality! There's reasonably no one who's acting terribly suspicious.

Also, stop having itchy trigger fingers. It's only to the mafia's benefit that we get an accidental majority lynch just because some people felt the need to cast a vote in their first post.

To be honest, I thought Ryan would be the first to go. He is clearly a very intelligent player who has a crazy ability to rationalize/manipulate. Based on this, I have to immediately suspect him, but I won't vote so quickly.

I THINK WE NEED TO CALM DOWN SO THAT WE DON'T MAKE A MISTAKE.

It's most likely we'll slip up in this round anyway. So in order to progress we need to knuckle our heads together and think of the most obvious Mafia member so far. The problem is, it's difficult to say. I reckon one of the Admins, or maybe more than one, are Mafia members. This is based on the fact they seem to be fighting over suspicions that they have gained in the real world. In conclusion they all seem to be manipulative, making them a lot more suspicious than any of the others here.

I understand this. But I think we're better off making a generally accepted educated guess.

We should all be working together to reason through this. We can all name who we're suspicious of, but everyone should retract their votes.

[Pats Freak 101]

I feel bad for whoever is counting votes....

I vote Ryan BTW.

[VS Admin]

Dec 28, 2010 11:23:10 GMT -8 Shiraz said:

Dec 28, 2010 9:31:23 GMT -8 VS Admin said:

I vote Ricky. I told him I was a villager and asked what he was and he wouldn't say. I can't trust him.

That makes you seem suspicious. =P We're not supposed to tell others what our roles are, anyway, so maybe you were trying to draw him out so you'd know if he was someone worth killing or not.

And just because people have logged in but not posted doesn't mean they're suspicious. They could be reading through the posts to try and figure out who to vote for before they finally post. That's not good enough grounds to lynch someone.

My current vote is the only logical vote that has been made to this point. No one is certain of who is or is not mafia.

I posted a list of who has not posted in this thread along with their last login dates. I believe it is suspicious for people to be online but not be posting here. It's better than some stab in the dark.

That's why I think we should be voting for Crow.

[Thesealion]

I am basing my vote on how the admins have been acting. I may change it later but so far Ryan seems the best bet.

[CheatAreZee]

I think I'll keep my vote retracted for the remainder of the round. Just wait and see what happens after tonight.

[Former Member]

Dec 28, 2010 11:36:37 GMT -8 CheatAreZee said:

I think I'll keep my vote retracted for the remainder of the round. Just wait and see what happens after tonight.

But why? If we all retract our votes and are indecisive then the Mafia will seize the opportunity to take another Villager down. The Mafia will now know who have got correct or close guesses, and will take down the most active and persuasive Villager. It would mean a blow to us. I say whoever the Detective is, investigate Patrick Clinger or Ryan as I'm very suspicious of them two. Shiraz is also another guess, as she's trying to confuse and manipulate us at the same time by implying certain people being Mafia.

My vote remains fixed upon RICKY

(Got names confuzzled)

[bagheera]

Dec 28, 2010 11:28:16 GMT -8 Pats Freak 101 said:

I feel bad for whoever is counting votes....

The bolding helps a lot. Thanks for doing it, guys.

Got it so far as:

Patrick Clinger: Crow
Ryan: Crow

Pats Freak 101: Ryan
Nightwalker: Ryan

Dominick: Ricky
Ryan Roos: Ricky
TheLostStocking: Ricky

As a reminder, 10 votes are necessary to lynch someone, and there's 19 people in the game right now.