GT Mafia: Round 2 ((Post-Game))

[Shiraz]

Dec 28, 2010 11:29:52 GMT -8 VS Admin said:

Dec 28, 2010 11:23:10 GMT -8 Shiraz said:

That makes you seem suspicious. =P We're not supposed to tell others what our roles are, anyway, so maybe you were trying to draw him out so you'd know if he was someone worth killing or not.

And just because people have logged in but not posted doesn't mean they're suspicious. They could be reading through the posts to try and figure out who to vote for before they finally post. That's not good enough grounds to lynch someone.

My current vote is the only logical vote that has been made to this point. No one is certain of who is or is not mafia.

I posted a list of who has not posted in this thread along with their last login dates. I believe it is suspicious for people to be online but not be posting here. It's better than some stab in the dark.

That's why I think we should be voting for Crow.

Perhaps! But I think people who are posting are more suspicious. Villagers, I think, would want to stay away from the spotlight so that the Mafia don't notice them and kill them.

The Mafia have less reason to stay away from the threads, because they'd want to kill/lynch people as quickly as possible before they're found out, and since there are several of them, it would be easy for them to gang up on one person, as opposed to the villagers who don't have any alliance with anyone.

Dec 28, 2010 11:41:53 GMT -8 @lostdawn said:

Dec 28, 2010 11:36:37 GMT -8 CheatAreZee said:

I think I'll keep my vote retracted for the remainder of the round. Just wait and see what happens after tonight.

But why? If we all retract our votes and are indecisive then the Mafia will seize the opportunity to take another Villager down. The Mafia will now know who have got correct or close guesses, and will take down the most active and persuasive Villager. It would mean a blow to us. I say whoever the Detective is, investigate Patrick Clinger or Ryan as I'm very suspicious of them two. Shiraz is also another guess, as she's trying to confuse and manipulate us at the same time by implying certain people being Mafia.

My vote remains fixed upon RICKY

(Got names confuzzled)

I'm just voicing my thoughts, not trying to lead anyone on. xD If someone picks on my posts and expands on them, they're more than welcome to do that.

Also, you are a fine example in what I said in my reply to Patrick. You want to go through this quickly, so you're going for the person with the most votes on their head. =]

[Former Member]

Dec 28, 2010 12:08:58 GMT -8 Shiraz said:

Dec 28, 2010 11:29:52 GMT -8 VS Admin said:

My current vote is the only logical vote that has been made to this point. No one is certain of who is or is not mafia.

I posted a list of who has not posted in this thread along with their last login dates. I believe it is suspicious for people to be online but not be posting here. It's better than some stab in the dark.

That's why I think we should be voting for Crow.

Perhaps! But I think people who are posting are more suspicious. Villagers, I think, would want to stay away from the spotlight so that the Mafia don't notice them and kill them.

The Mafia have less reason to stay away from the threads, because they'd want to kill/lynch people as quickly as possible before they're found out, and since there are several of them, it would be easy for them to gang up on one person, as opposed to the villagers who don't have any alliance with anyone.



But why? If we all retract our votes and are indecisive then the Mafia will seize the opportunity to take another Villager down. The Mafia will now know who have got correct or close guesses, and will take down the most active and persuasive Villager. It would mean a blow to us. I say whoever the Detective is, investigate Patrick Clinger or Ryan as I'm very suspicious of them two. Shiraz is also another guess, as she's trying to confuse and manipulate us at the same time by implying certain people being Mafia.

My vote remains fixed upon RICKY

(Got names confuzzled)

I'm just voicing my thoughts, not trying to lead anyone on. xD If someone picks on my posts and expands on them, they're more than welcome to do that.

Also, you are a fine example in what I said in my reply to Patrick. You want to go through this quickly, so you're going for the person with the most votes on their head. =] [/quote]

I'm not going to theperson with the most votes, as I have planned it out fairly carefully. Ricky isn't voting to lynch anyone, which is strange for a Villager to do, isn't it? A Villager would want to take the risk of hitting someone, to further evidence/suspicions. We get little to no evidence of who the Mafia are from the Night phase. We get evidence from behaviour etc. And as I said, you were implying at first that one of the Staff members were Mafia. Then you protest when people do vote for a member of staff? Strange isn't it. I've got my eye on you.

[Matej]

After reading this thread and seeing some of the responses the most "obvious" choice for me here was Ryan.
Almost seems like he's trying to accuse others, I dunno, that's what I got from everything.
Bit of a rush, so that's all I can say right now.

[Ryan Roos]

Wow Woop, thanks for that vote of confidence.

Also Bagheera you accidentally have me voting twice in your last post. I vote for CROW not Ricky, although I must admit his sudden lack of voting does seem strange.

[Former Member]

Why is everyone voting for Crow? Give her a chance to defend herself, she's not here yet, and that's not cold hard evidence is it? Ricky has a slight change in his behaviour, as one minute ago he was arguing about Ryan being Mafia, then Crow and finally just says "Ah I'll pull my vote out". It's very, very odd. It's already been suggested that he was Mafia, and is so far the most consistent at providing evidence towards him being Mafia. I say we take a shot, and see if it works. I'm not 100% sure, but I think it's him more than anybody else. Plus I'd rather lynch him than lynch nobody at all, and let another Villager suffer. Think tactically, what if tonight the Mafia remove the Detective or the Doctor. Both of them offer values we need, and will cause an impact on the game if removed. Think it through. Vote for no evidence, over some evidence?

[bagheera]

The votes go person first, then who they're voting for, in my current table. Fixed it, too.

Therefore...

---

Player -- Vote
Patrick Clinger: Crow
Ryan: Crow

Pats Freak 101: Ryan
Nightwalker: Ryan
woop: Ryan

Dominick: Ricky
TheLostStocking: Ricky

[CheatAreZee]

Based on the evidence provided, Patricks suggestion for Crow would be logical, but using that same logic at this point, Zar appears to be just as much of a suspect as well. If I do make a voting decision, it'll be after everyone has spoke up so I can make a real judgment call.

Lost Stocking: I never spoke about Crow before this post. Up until now, I only spoke of Ryan

[Shiraz]

Dec 28, 2010 12:40:36 GMT -8 @lostdawn said:

I'm not going to theperson with the most votes, as I have planned it out fairly carefully. Ricky isn't voting to lynch anyone, which is strange for a Villager to do, isn't it? A Villager would want to take the risk of hitting someone, to further evidence/suspicions. We get little to no evidence of who the Mafia are from the Night phase. We get evidence from behaviour etc. And as I said, you were implying at first that one of the Staff members were Mafia. Then you protest when people do vote for a member of staff? Strange isn't it. I've got my eye on you.

I haven't actually voted yet, have I? I still didn't rule out the staff, and I'm not protesting when people vote for a member of a staff. =P I was merely stating that you joined the others when they voted for Nightwalker, then you joined them again when they voted for Ricky. That's all. xD

And Ricky still has time to vote, and so does everyone else. Instead of voting and retracting his vote, maybe he wants to make one final vote? I mean, I know I want to do that.

[Former Member]

Dec 28, 2010 12:54:56 GMT -8 CheatAreZee said:

Based on the evidence provided, Patricks suggestion for Crow would be logical, but using that same logic at this point, Zar appears to be just as much of a suspect as well. If I do make a voting decision, it'll be after everyone has spoke up so I can make a real judgment call.

Lost Stocking: I never spoke about Crow before this post. Up until now, I only spoke of Ryan

Sorry Ricky, I keep getting the votes confused. I feel sorry for Bagheera.

shiraz:

I voted for Nightwalker because at the time I wanted a quick round. Then certain information was revealed, and the final cog clicked into place, and I decided I was going to be a stubborn git and persist with my Ricky vote. I'll be observing you and Ryan though, don't worry about that. And if you read Ricky's post, he said he wasn't going to vote this round, and was going to wait it out. Do you not think that's fishy? It's in the best interest for the Mafia to try and stay away from arguments so they are not lynched in the first round. Was have watched Ricky try and conceal himself by having a small argument with Ryan, and then he suddenly retracts his vote and lurks about. Fishy huh?

[Ryan Roos]

I think everyone will be watching me. That's why I'm scared.

[Phaelyn]

Dec 28, 2010 13:14:10 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

I think everyone will be watching me. That's why I'm scared.

Truthfully, I'm sort of trusting you, so far. Either you've totally toned down or are actually innocent xD

[Former Member]

Dec 28, 2010 13:14:10 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

I think everyone will be watching me. That's why I'm scared.

I wouldn't be worried Ryan, I think you're more likely a Villager by the way you aren't manipulating people in this game. I'm watching you because your good at this game, and I know you can be deceptive, so I'm very much hoping that you are on my side rather than the Mafia's.

[Thesealion]

Ryan doesn't seem to be manipulating as hard this game. Ricky seems to want to defend himself. Also this not voting thing has me going. The mafia are ok if we don't lynch anyone so i think they may try to get us to do that...

[Phaelyn]

Night, I'm not voting yet simply because I don't know who to vote for It's the first round and we have zero evidence xD

[Ryan Roos]

Currently my entire strategy rests in trusting Pat. He has provided the only sound logic for narrowing down people at all.

If you are trusting me, I say let's trust Pat for at least today. Pat says Crow, so I say Crow.

I think a no vote is not the way to go under any circumstances. So join Pat or vote for someone else. But at least vote.