GT Mafia: Round 2 ((Post-Game))

[Thesealion]

That is not what i meant. I was talking about Ricky saying he wasn't going to vote at all. I don't know if it means anything yet but it is something to look into.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Dec 28, 2010 13:46:56 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Currently my entire strategy rests in trusting Pat. He has provided the only sound logic for narrowing down people at all.

If you are trusting me, I say let's trust Pat for at least today. Pat says Crow, so I say Crow.

I think a no vote is not the way to go under any circumstances. So join Pat or vote for someone else. But at least vote.

True, but if I remember correctly, patrick seems to be doing a lot of work trying to frame people. That leaves me suspicious, but as of yet I have no evidence

[VS Admin]

If you notice, I posted first to try to get things moving. Just as everyone knows, at this point in the game it's very hard to guess who is or isn't mafia, so I tried to think of what I would consider the best 'evidence' of who could be mafia.

My thought process is that mafia want to lay low early while us villagers argue with eachother and point fingers. If you don't post you avoid having people focus on you. So I think we should turn that around.

I listed three people in my post that had been online after the daytime started, I would vote for any of them. It's nothing personal, it's just the best logic I have for who we should go after to have better odds in killing a mafia member.

For the record, I am a villager. I did not receive a PM with any special role. You'll probably find that out when I die about half way through the game when people think me posting too much is suspicious

[Former Member]

Dec 28, 2010 14:15:06 GMT -8 VS Admin said:

If you notice, I posted first to try to get things moving. Just as everyone knows, at this point in the game it's very hard to guess who is or isn't mafia, so I tried to think of what I would consider the best 'evidence' of who could be mafia.

My thought process is that mafia want to lay low early while us villagers argue with eachother and point fingers. If you don't post you avoid having people focus on you. So I think we should turn that around.

I listed three people in my post that had been online after the daytime started, I would vote for any of them. It's nothing personal, it's just the best logic I have for who we should go after to have better odds in killing a mafia member.

For the record, I am a villager. I did not receive a PM with any special role. You'll probably find that out when I die about half way through the game when people think me posting too much is suspicious

Posting too much is nothing that I take into account. Look how much I have posted so far, to try and pinpoint the Mafia and reveal certain people's motives. I also, had no special role message sent to me, and received the standard one saying that the game had started. I am hoping to spot weird behaviour within the Mafia's actions. So yeah, if you get voted off by posting too much, then I'll get voted for posting the most.

I was suspicious of you at first, and believed that Ryan might be a sheep to a member of the Mafia but I'm starting to change my mind. I believe you and Ryan to be Villagers, but I am very convinced that Ricky is in the Mafia. Just think about it. Give Crow and others time, as if they don't post next time, like they haven't this time. Then I'll be suspicious. But Ricky stands out the most. I say the non-voters take a look at Ricky's behaviour since he started posting, and then try and criticize this.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Well I can't exactly read you to be honest. You have suggested many people on the first day, but like you said there has yet to be any hard evidence on anybody. I say for now we just make sure to lynch somebody otherwise the mafia get an extra night to kill whomever they please.

[VS Admin]

Dec 28, 2010 14:27:52 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Well I can't exactly read you to be honest. You have suggested many people on the first day, but like you said there has yet to be any hard evidence on anybody. I say for now we just make sure to lynch somebody otherwise the mafia get an extra night to kill whomever they please.

Exactly. If we don't pick someone then all that happens is another villager dies in the night. Hopefully the detective will start to build a coalition of villagers (that they identify as villagers) or steer our discussion towards mafia members they find.

[Thesealion]

Well i think we can trust Patrick.

Tell me if i am wrong here but...

Did Bagheera say anything about how if you didn't get a message you were a villager? So if she didn't then would Pat take the chance in saying, "I didn't get a message." How was he to know that Bagheera didn't send a message to the villagers?

Am i stretching things?

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Dec 28, 2010 14:36:50 GMT -8 Thesealion said:

Well i think we can trust Patrick.

Tell me if i am wrong here but...

Did Bagheera say anything about how if you didn't get a message you were a villager? So if she didn't then would Pat take the chance in saying, "I didn't get a message." How was he to know that Bagheera didn't send a message to the villagers?

Am i stretching things?

didn't bagheeramention that earlier in the thread though? I know I was on the cusp of sending her a pm myself asking whether or not villagers were supposed to get a pm telling us we were villagers, but I thought she mentioned it sikh where. I'd check the thread myself but I'm within 30 mb of going over my mobile data for the month and each pb page load is about 1.50 mb, so I have to be careful.

[Alex Zechiel]

I'm not at the office this week, but based solely on their posts, I think it's far more likely that Pat and Ryan are mafia than Ricky. If I die soon, it's because I'm on to them. I vote Ryan (sorry Ryan!).

[Syko Nachoman]

After quickly reading through several pages of this thread, neither Ricky, Ryan, or Crow seem suspicious to me at all, despite all of them having lots of votes. The two who appear most suspicious are Patrick and Nightwalker. However, since neither of them have any votes, and it seems unlikely that either will be lynched today, I'll hold onto my vote for now and wait to see how this develops.

[VS Admin]

removed bad information

[Former Member]

Dec 28, 2010 14:52:52 GMT -8 Syko Nachoman said:

After quickly reading through several pages of this thread, neither Ricky, Ryan, or Crow seem suspicious to me at all, despite all of them having lots of votes. The two who appear most suspicious are Patrick and Nightwalker. However, since neither of them have any votes, and it seems unlikely that either will be lynched today, I'll hold onto my vote for now and wait to see how this develops.

What brings you to this conclusion Syko? Why Patrick and Nightwalker? They seem to be good Samaritans just trying to pinpoint the Mafia.

[Syko Nachoman]

Dec 28, 2010 14:53:01 GMT -8 VS Admin said:

[red]Did anyone else receive a "the game has started" PM from Bagheera??[/red]

I did.

Dec 28, 2010 14:55:47 GMT -8 @lostdawn said:

Dec 28, 2010 14:52:52 GMT -8 Syko Nachoman said:

After quickly reading through several pages of this thread, neither Ricky, Ryan, or Crow seem suspicious to me at all, despite all of them having lots of votes. The two who appear most suspicious are Patrick and Nightwalker. However, since neither of them have any votes, and it seems unlikely that either will be lynched today, I'll hold onto my vote for now and wait to see how this develops.

What brings you to this conclusion Syko? Why Patrick and Nightwalker? They seem to be good Samaritans just trying to pinpoint the Mafia.

It's not a conclusion, just a hunch. Both of them seem to have been acting defensively. Although Nightwalker stopped doing so a while ago, so I'm starting to have second thoughts about his affiliation.

[VS Admin]

Edit: Ok, went back through my PMs and found it. Someone at work must have accidentally clicked one of my PMs and had it mark as read. I revoke my previous claim.

[Former Member]

Dec 28, 2010 14:59:54 GMT -8 Syko Nachoman said:

Dec 28, 2010 14:53:01 GMT -8 VS Admin said:

[red]Did anyone else receive a "the game has started" PM from Bagheera??[/red]

I did.



What brings you to this conclusion Syko? Why Patrick and Nightwalker? They seem to be good Samaritans just trying to pinpoint the Mafia.

It's not a conclusion, just a hunch. Both of them seem to have been acting defensively. Although Nightwalker stopped doing so a while ago, so I'm starting to have second thoughts about his affiliation.
[/quote]

Okay then, sorry about that. But I can see Patrick is trying to trick the Mafia into saying who they are.