ProBoards Mafia Game 4 (POST-GAME)

[Ace Trainer Dom]

I would like to know what made me stand out as well, for future reference of course. If we have better players the game is more interesting

[Syko Nachoman]

Feb 2, 2011 12:27:57 GMT -8 Dove said:

Ryan how did you know I was mafia?

I don't know why Ryan suspected you, but I can give you the reason I shot you -- I suspected you of being the Double-Agent who had been holding things up during that one night phase. (And also, on reviewing your posts, you seemed very enthusiastic to lynch several people who all turned out to be villagers )

[Ryan Roos]

Feb 2, 2011 12:27:57 GMT -8 Dove said:

Ryan how did you know I was mafia?

I had no idea you were mafia. You weren't even on my radar. The gunsmith killed you (or syko).

That was just luck. I thought Andrea was the fifth til you died and then realized Andrea or Dom was a villager. I picked Andrea after talking to Adam.

[Andrea]

Feb 2, 2011 12:36:36 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Feb 2, 2011 12:27:57 GMT -8 Dove said:

Ryan how did you know I was mafia?

I had no idea you were mafia. You weren't even on my radar. The gunsmith killed you (or syko).

That was just luck. I thought Andrea was the fifth til you died and then realized Andrea or Dom was a villager. I picked Andrea after talking to Adam.

Haha, and how did Adam convince you?

I wasn't kidding when I told you that Phaelyn forgot to PM me my role because it was so insignificant.

I'm just glad I wasn't killed too early.

[bagheera]

So... why was I suspicious? I was acting pretty much like I would as a villager (or so I thought)... my advice was all based on exactly what I'd say if I were a villager (going for a no-lynch, etc), I just did extra stuff at night. So what made me stand out?

And congrats, guys. You done good. ;D No hard feelings, I hope... looking forward to the next game already.

[VS Admin]

Just for the record, when the mafia decided to kill me I had made a point of making myself a target and even told Adam to protect me that night. He didn't protect himself. He didn't protect me. He protected woop! Sigh...

Anyways, good game everyone, we'll be posting signups for the next game shortly. The admins will also be discussing who will narrate and roles to ensure the game runs more smoothly next time around.

Since we haven't had a mafia win yet after 4 games (IMO it should be 50/50) we will be tweaking the roles slightly to go in the mafia's favor more than it is now.

[Ryan Roos]

Feb 2, 2011 12:40:35 GMT -8 bagheera said:

So... why was I suspicious? I was acting pretty much like I would as a villager (or so I thought)... my advice was all based on exactly what I'd say if I were a villager (going for a no-lynch, etc), I just did extra stuff at night. So what made me stand out?

And congrats, guys. You done good. ;D No hard feelings, I hope... looking forward to the next game already.

You jumped on the Trill bandwagon sooooo fast. That brought attention to you. Then I noticed you were playing different than game one and you kept trying to be my friend. It was too drastic from the last time we played together. I wasn't 100% sure about you but you made the most sense at the time.

When you died my other floated up based on voting patterns and behavior related to you.

[Phaelyn]

Feb 2, 2011 12:41:38 GMT -8 VS Admin said:

The admins will also be discussing who will narrate and roles to ensure the game runs more smoothly next time around.

sorry >.< I did my best, haha.

[Dove]

Oh yeah sorry, I meant syko, haha, and okay thankyou.

[Syko Nachoman]

Feb 2, 2011 12:27:13 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

I'll make some of the achievements now

...er, any suggestions for the format? I can't find any good trophy images >_>

Use the Message Icons

Document Award
Best Idea-Haver Award
Worst Something-or-Other Ever Award

Endless possibilities

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Feb 2, 2011 12:42:58 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Feb 2, 2011 12:40:35 GMT -8 bagheera said:

So... why was I suspicious? I was acting pretty much like I would as a villager (or so I thought)... my advice was all based on exactly what I'd say if I were a villager (going for a no-lynch, etc), I just did extra stuff at night. So what made me stand out?

And congrats, guys. You done good. ;D No hard feelings, I hope... looking forward to the next game already.

You jumped on the Trill bandwagon sooooo fast. That brought attention to you. Then I noticed you were playing different than game one and you kept trying to be my friend. It was too drastic from the last time we played together. I wasn't 100% sure about you but you made the most sense at the time.

When you died my other floated up based on voting patterns and behavior related to you.

So you connected bagheera's voting pattern with the rest of us? That's smart


And patrick, I notice you said the admins will be discussing future games. I would like to just say I am interested in narrating future games. I am very active here and keeping up with the game should be no problem as long as the game doesn't start this weekend (Super bowl means I'm stuck wherever my parents decide to go, meaning no internet )

[Andrea]

Feb 2, 2011 12:48:28 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Feb 2, 2011 12:42:58 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

You jumped on the Trill bandwagon sooooo fast. That brought attention to you. Then I noticed you were playing different than game one and you kept trying to be my friend. It was too drastic from the last time we played together. I wasn't 100% sure about you but you made the most sense at the time.

When you died my other floated up based on voting patterns and behavior related to you.

So you connected bagheera's voting pattern with the rest of us? That's smart


And patrick, I notice you said the admins will be discussing future games. I would like to just say I am interested in narrating future games. I am very active here and keeping up with the game should be no problem as long as the game doesn't start this weekend (Super bowl means I'm stuck wherever my parents decide to go, meaning no internet )

Trill was next wasn't he?

Or not, he's doing a different game.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Feb 2, 2011 12:53:19 GMT -8 Andrea said:

Feb 2, 2011 12:48:28 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

So you connected bagheera's voting pattern with the rest of us? That's smart


And patrick, I notice you said the admins will be discussing future games. I would like to just say I am interested in narrating future games. I am very active here and keeping up with the game should be no problem as long as the game doesn't start this weekend (Super bowl means I'm stuck wherever my parents decide to go, meaning no internet )

Trill was next wasn't he?

Yes, I'm just including my name for the narrator pool in case they decide to pick narrators rather than using the waiting list I don't know, I just want them to know I'm interested in narrating, I think I will do a great job

[Thesealion]

Feb 2, 2011 12:48:28 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Feb 2, 2011 12:42:58 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

You jumped on the Trill bandwagon sooooo fast. That brought attention to you. Then I noticed you were playing different than game one and you kept trying to be my friend. It was too drastic from the last time we played together. I wasn't 100% sure about you but you made the most sense at the time.

When you died my other floated up based on voting patterns and behavior related to you.

So you connected bagheera's voting pattern with the rest of us? That's smart


And patrick, I notice you said the admins will be discussing future games. I would like to just say I am interested in narrating future games. I am very active here and keeping up with the game should be no problem as long as the game doesn't start this weekend (Super bowl means I'm stuck wherever my parents decide to go, meaning no internet )

Yea me too. I was talking to Phae about doing one at some point but i never got word as to weather i could do it or not...

I have been active before this game i just was out of town and now i am having power troubles but i should be comming back in the next few days...

[Trill]

Oh yeah, I knew bagheera was Mafia and you killed me! > haha she had the same idea of being against the "send X your roles" strategy just like I had when I was the Godfather.

---

Feel free to join Who's The Boss (a similar socio-strategy forum-based game).