Mafia! Game 5 (After Party)

[★Fuzzy★]

*Wakes up and is disappointed at the lack of daytime. Goes back to sleep*

[Ben Woodruff]

wakes up
rolls over to look a the clock
curses
rolls back over and goes back to sleep

[aether]

WELCOME TO THE MOURNING NEWS HOUR

"Welcome folks. My name is Rita Book and I am your news anchor this morning. It is 11 minutes past the hour. In TOP NEWS today, "celebrity" Kim Kardashian picked up the evening paper yesterday to look at the daily fame whoroscope. She was shocked and dismayed to see a picture of HERSELF in the reading. In a fit of unpleasantness or what some are calling celebration of her fame, she hit up the local clubs and got embarrassingly drunk. More on that story when we sift through and find the most exploitive pictures to show you all. Now, with more, and surely less interesting news, I hand it over to Benjamin Dover. Ben?


Hey folks. In other news, the town of Proboardia was struck hard last night with the murder of one if its patrons. It was quite an unusual death. The villager, woop, was hung, drawn and quartered, poisoned and shot 4 times in the back. The report states it as attempted and successful suicide, but there will be continuing investigations to look into the matter.

And that's all for the news, friends. This is Ben Dover telling you to have a good day.

[Ben Woodruff]

One of our citizens was just murdered. This was no suicide attempt gone right. The mafia is afoot.

Feb 8, 2011 20:20:13 GMT -8 Trill said:

Were only mafia and special roles PMd? I assume roles were distributed by now.

I vote we lynch Trill. I think this post it a ploy to make himself look innocent.

[Phaelyn]

Feb 9, 2011 8:48:53 GMT -8 Ben Woodruff said:

One of our citizens was just murdered. This was no suicide attempt gone right. The mafia is afoot.

Feb 8, 2011 20:20:13 GMT -8 Trill said:

Were only mafia and special roles PMd? I assume roles were distributed by now.

I vote we lynch Trill. I think this post it a ploy to make himself look innocent.

I'm not about to throw out a vote just yet, but I don't think this makes Trill suspicious -- in fact, it makes you a bit more suspicious because you sort of just jumped on him, haha. It was a completely valid question -- from other games, I assumed that no pm = no special role, but Trill hadn't been in the original one, which was like that as well. Plus, where would he have found out that villagers didn't get PMs in the first place?

[Ben Woodruff]

Feb 9, 2011 8:59:00 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Plus, where would he have found out that villagers didn't get PMs in the first place?

I think this shows he was well aware of the rules and only posted his question to try and divert attention from the fact that he did receive a PM.

It was clearly illustrated during the first game, by bagheera, that villagers don't get PMs (I read the entire thread in preparation).

[Ryan Roos]

I support Trill too
anyone could be guilty
it's only day one

[VS Admin]

I'm voting No Lynch since it's the first day.

[Phaelyn]

Feb 9, 2011 9:08:53 GMT -8 Ben Woodruff said:

Feb 9, 2011 8:59:00 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Plus, where would he have found out that villagers didn't get PMs in the first place?

I think this shows he was well aware of the rules and only posted his question to try and divert attention from the fact that he did receive a PM.

It was clearly illustrated during the first game, by bagheera, that villagers don't get PMs (I read the entire thread in preparation).

However, in two of the other games -- Ryan's and mine -- villagers did receive PMs. Trill played in both of those games.

[Ben Woodruff]

Feb 9, 2011 9:21:43 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Feb 9, 2011 9:08:53 GMT -8 Ben Woodruff said:

I think this shows he was well aware of the rules and only posted his question to try and divert attention from the fact that he did receive a PM.

It was clearly illustrated during the first game, by bagheera, that villagers don't get PMs (I read the entire thread in preparation).

However, in two of the other games -- Ryan's and mine -- villagers did receive PMs. Trill played in both of those games.

Ah, I thought that was a common thread. Either way, my vote stands, for now.

[Andrea]

I'm surprised Patrick that you are voting a no lynch. In all games, you are always so eager to get a lynching out of the way so we don't waste our time.

Anyway, I agree with Phaelyn. Just because Trill asked that doesn't make him mafia just because the two first rounds were played that way. The last two rounds were played where all roles received a PM, and since Aether had made no mention of whether or not he was going to send everyone a PM, it was a pretty valid question. Nobody started sleeping until Aether clarified that all roles had been PMed. Except Jetta, who mentioned that she was waiting for role clarification as well.

I may vote Trill, but will hold off for now.

[Alex Zechiel]

I'm with Pat on this one (and this is mainly aimed at Ryan and Ben who are throwing out names super early in the game and in the day). So far, every game, we've done no lynch, except for the game where we killed the detective DAY ONE. I think voting Trill would be a bad idea.

No Lynch

edit:

Feb 9, 2011 9:25:06 GMT -8 Andrea said:

I'm surprised Patrick that you are voting a no lynch. In all games, you are always so eager to get a lynching out of the way so we don't waste our time.

That's probably because he doesn't want a repeat of when Adam got killed day one.

[VS Admin]

Feb 9, 2011 9:25:06 GMT -8 Andrea said:

I'm surprised Patrick that you are voting a no lynch. In all games, you are always so eager to get a lynching out of the way so we don't waste our time.

Anyway, I agree with Phaelyn. Just because Trill asked that doesn't make him mafia just because the two first rounds were played that way. The last two rounds were played where all roles received a PM, and since Aether had made no mention of whether or not he was going to send everyone a PM, it was a pretty valid question. Nobody started sleeping until Aether clarified that all roles had been PMed. Except Jetta, who mentioned that she was waiting for role clarification as well.

I may vote Trill, but will hold off for now.

Yeah, and last time I ended up getting the detective killed by getting a train of people to kill Adam if you remember I figure I'll switch it to No Lynch so the village detective can do some work.

[Ben Woodruff]

Feb 9, 2011 9:26:14 GMT -8 Alex Zechiel said:

I'm with Pat on this one (and this is mainly aimed at Ryan and Ben who are throwing out names super early in the game and in the day). So far, every game, we've done no lynch, except for the game where we killed the detective DAY ONE. I think voting Trill would be a bad idea.

No Lynch

I'm confident Trill is not the detective, for the same reason I'm confident he is a mafioso.

[VS Admin]

Ben, what evidence do you have for this claim?