Mafia! Game 5 (After Party)

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Excuse me but Pikachu is not for eating. Everyone knows the Pikachu is too tough and it always burns. Now Tauros is good, and Bulbasaur makes a great vegetarian option

And what the frak? Why does this always happen

[Phaelyn]

I vote Patrick. I can't give you guys any evidence about him right now, so you'll just have to act on faith, but he PM'd me yesterday saying that he was the detective, and that he investigated me and I came up clean. Since I'm a villager, I obviously took the bait

If you guys don't believe me, it doesn't hurt to lynch him. If he turns out to be a special role or whatever, have at me. We need to do this today, especially since I'll likely be dead tomorrow for this

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Tell you what, if you die tonight, we should lynch patrick



Kidding Patrick sounds good to me. I would like to claim his castle when he dies though

[Trill]

Last game Patrick told me he was going to act as a fake detective pretty much for the lols. Don't know if he's still doing that now, but if you're impersonating the detective, that's one of the only leads we have.

Patrick

[Phaelyn]

Feb 9, 2011 19:57:45 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Tell you what, if you die tonight, we should lynch patrick

I'm not much help after I'm dead, am I doesn't make much difference if you all would rather wait a day, I'm counting on the fact that I'll likely be killed tonight anyway. However, remember that if we don't lynch Patrick today, the mafia might wait on killing me and get the rest of you to lynch me yourselves, setting you all back a day.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Feb 9, 2011 19:58:35 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Feb 9, 2011 19:57:45 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Tell you what, if you die tonight, we should lynch patrick

I'm not much help after I'm dead, am I doesn't make much difference if you all would rather wait a day, I'm counting on the fact that I'll likely be killed tonight anyway. However, remember that if we don't lynch Patrick today, the mafia might wait on killing me and get the rest of you to lynch me yourselves, setting you all back a day.

Well it was a ploy to try and keep you alive an extra day if Patrick was mafia, but thinking about it made me realize it probably wouldn't work in our favor, so I changed it

[Phaelyn]

Feb 9, 2011 20:01:37 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Feb 9, 2011 19:58:35 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

I'm not much help after I'm dead, am I doesn't make much difference if you all would rather wait a day, I'm counting on the fact that I'll likely be killed tonight anyway. However, remember that if we don't lynch Patrick today, the mafia might wait on killing me and get the rest of you to lynch me yourselves, setting you all back a day.

Well it was a ploy to try and keep you alive an extra day if Patrick was mafia, but thinking about it made me realize it probably wouldn't work in our favor, so I changed it

Thank you.

Also, guys, just so you know, if you want hard proof that I'm a villager, PM me. It involves linking you offsite to a different mafia discussion, so... sorry.

Also, Patrick, if you're being the detective just for lols, I will lynch you again after everyone else lynches you.

[Syko Nachoman]

Feb 9, 2011 19:56:10 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

I vote Patrick. I can't give you guys any evidence about him right now, so you'll just have to act on faith, but he PM'd me yesterday saying that he was the detective, and that he investigated me and I came up clean. Since I'm a villager, I obviously took the bait

If you guys don't believe me, it doesn't hurt to lynch him. If he turns out to be a special role or whatever, have at me. We need to do this today, especially since I'll likely be dead tomorrow for this

So it's either you or him? All right then. It seems like Patrick always dies early in the game, though.

Patrick

[Adam]

There is only one type of good fake-detective.

Patrick

[Pepper]

'Tis the best lead we have. Patrick.

[Ben Woodruff]

Dom: Sure, I take PayPal. Though why you wouldn't just order your own is a bit beyond me...

Hmm. So if what Phaelyn says is true, that doesn't necessarily make Patrick mafioso does it? I mean, it's sketchy sure, but mafioso? I still have my doubts, and would like to hear what Pat has to say before I vote.

[Mr. Spartan]

Patrick

[Ben Woodruff]

Damn, everyone is really quick to take Phaelyn at her word and jump on Patrick. Don't you think we are being a bit hasty here?
I certainly buy that he could be, but wouldn't it be wise to wait and see some more solid evidence? At least hear what the man has to say for himself?

I realize this is totally contradictory from my attitude during day 1.

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Feb 9, 2011 20:22:33 GMT -8 Ben Woodruff said:

Dom: Sure, I take PayPal. Though why you wouldn't just order your own is a bit beyond me...

Hmm. So if what Phaelyn says is true, that doesn't necessarily make Patrick mafioso does it? I mean, it's sketchy sure, but mafioso? I still have my doubts, and would like to hear what Pat has to say before I vote.

You have Amazon Prime. My trial expired last weekend , I like free two-day shipping

Feb 9, 2011 20:25:20 GMT -8 Ben Woodruff said:

Damn, everyone is really quick to take Phaelyn at her word and jump on Patrick. Don't you think we are being a bit hasty here?
I certainly buy that he could be, but wouldn't it be wise to wait and see some more solid evidence? At least hear what the man has to say for himself?

I said that for three straight games but no one listened to me. Therefore I no longer bother to try and get people to slow down

[Ben Woodruff]

Feb 9, 2011 20:26:03 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Feb 9, 2011 20:22:33 GMT -8 Ben Woodruff said:

Dom: Sure, I take PayPal. Though why you wouldn't just order your own is a bit beyond me...

Hmm. So if what Phaelyn says is true, that doesn't necessarily make Patrick mafioso does it? I mean, it's sketchy sure, but mafioso? I still have my doubts, and would like to hear what Pat has to say before I vote.

You have Amazon Prime. My trial expired last weekend , I like free two-day shipping

heh, I have the free deal for students. Sure. I can help you out.