Mafia v8 [Game over]

[Former Member]

See the second @dmage retracted his vote for me, we get a wall of text from Robyn!

If you want to see a bolded vote, then here it is! - I apologise if you are not mafia, but as you said we only have to go on what we've seen happen in the thread. - And that's exactly what I'm going on. I've explained my reasons in depth now.

Robert

[Former Member]

Lets just say. I'm next on the death list here.

But if Robert is mafia, or he could be the doctor. But what sucks is if he is a doctor and were sick. How do we get treated? XD

Anyways

I'm still thinking. I will her what red says first.

[Robyn]

That wall of text is called defending yourself. You must have not read through it properly. Oh well

I'm still not voting for anyone because I honestly don't know who's mafia. If it's me, then I wouldn't have posted so willingly, wouln't you think?

[Former Member]

Hm interesting,

also something else that's interesting, we haven't heard much at all from RedBassett

[Former Member]

I was hoping for a post from RedBassett before I did anything. If he abstains from voting, it won't matter what we do since there won't be a lynching anyway, will there? He's the one that thought it was suspicious that I didn't want to lynch anyone, so I'm expecting a vote of some kind. I'll check back in a bit.

[Former Member]

Ok, if Red doesn't post by the end of the day, my vote will be ZAR

Sorry babe. But I'm 50% sure.

[Robyn]

Sounds good. I'll wait as well.

[Former Member]

@zar has done nothing to indicate (to me) that he is mafia. Robyn posting a big defensive wall of text after finding ZAR suspicious for defending himself earlier strikes me as odd, but not odd enough to get a vote from me one way or the other. @dmage hasn't done anything fishy at all. RedBassett, on the other hand, thought it was suspicious that I didn't want to lynch anyone and now is conveniently absent when we are casting votes. If he has not posted by the time the day phase ends, my vote will be for him. I know it's unlikely that he received the mafia role twice in a row, but it's just a gut feeling...

RedBassett

[Former Member]

Dec 19, 2014 13:51:59 GMT -8 @kipp said:

@zar has done nothing to indicate (to me) that he is mafia. Robyn posting a big defensive wall of text after finding ZAR suspicious for defending himself earlier strikes me as odd, but not odd enough to get a vote from me one way or the other. @dmage hasn't done anything fishy at all. RedBassett, on the other hand, thought it was suspicious that I didn't want to lynch anyone and now is conveniently absent when we are casting votes. If he has not posted by the time the day phase ends, my vote will be for him. I know it's unlikely that he received the mafia role twice in a row, but it's just a gut feeling...

RedBassett

Just because we don't do anything fishy doesn't mean one of us isn't the Guy. I could be it, and you wouldn't know. 

[Robyn]

This suddenly became very hard. I guess anyone of us could be it.

[Syko Nachoman]

Day 1 has officially ended (as of 5:19 PM EST). Let me go try to figure out who everyone voted for.

[Syko Nachoman]

Nothing Happens

After a day filled with accusations and additional accusations, each more accusatory than the last, the village failed to reach a consensus on who was to blame for Phaelyn's death. In an effort to relieve the tension, everyone then got together for a friendly round of hot chocolate and s'mores (not pictured in above discussion).

---

@dmage RedBassett @zar Robyn @kipp

Night roles, PM me your things.

[RedBassett]

Dec 19, 2014 0:01:46 GMT -8 @kipp said:

RedBassett: Why would I try to convince everyone not to lynch anyone if I was mafia unless I was the suggested lynchee? (That's totally a word now, by the way.) If I was mafia, wouldn't it be playing right into my hands if you guys never missed a day killing each other off? Maybe I'm not seeing this from all angles, but it just seems like we're helping the mafia by killing someone without anything to go off of. Then again, I'll concede that we'll never really have a lot to go off of and inaction won't help us either.

I just like pointing fingers. I'm voting:

And I was too late to vote

[Former Member]

Dec 19, 2014 14:27:04 GMT -8 @dmage said:

Just because we don't do anything fishy doesn't mean one of us isn't the Guy. I could be it, and you wouldn't know. 

No, but it does up the chances. You're the one accusing ZAR just because, 50% sure for no reason. I feel as if I had just as much reason to vote on RedBassett as you did on ZAR. I never said RedBassett was, without a doubt, mafia. Just that I had a strong feeling he was.

Ah well. Hot chocolate and s'mores it is.

[Former Member]

So true. I see your point!