Mafia v8 [Game over]

[Syko Nachoman]

Robert Dies, Too

As morning rose, normal villager Robyn was found dead. The circumstances surrounding his death remain a mystery, mostly because the town's only detective isn't around to provide further details anymore.

---

@dmage RedBassett @zar @kipp

Day 2 officially begins with this post.

[Former Member]

I knew Robert was being framed! So far we got me, Red, ZAR, and Chani.

Hmmm. *Contemplates*

[Former Member]

Very interesting, so I was wrong about Robert. - Although why would the mafia member kill off Robert? He was a prime suspect. You'd want to keep him alive to keep yourself under the radar... That's a poor move in my book

I'm swining towards @kipp / RedBassett now.

@kipp seems to have a very keen interest in this game, and getting in to reply. That suggests to me maybe she has something to hide? She needs to check the thread often to build a picture perhaps.

Also it doesn't help any of us that RedBassett hasn't been saying much at all, we've got nothing to go on. Although if he was Mafia, he'd probably make more of an effort to post, because otherwise it would automatically raise suspicion.

I'm swinging towards @kipp

[Former Member]

I can't have a "keen interest" in this game because I feel terrible that I totally missed the last one? If I was mafia, I wouldn't need to post this much, would I? I could just pop in often enough to avoid suspicion. I wouldn't have suggested that we not lynch anyone and I certainly would have voted that we lynch you on the first day, because that would have been one less person. You are seriously underestimating my mafia skills if you think it's me.

I think you're just slinging out accusations because you realize that you're in the hot seat now. You make an excellent point, actually! Why would someone get rid of Robert when you're so intent on having him lynched?

Well, I can think of one person, at least.

[Robyn]

-The awkward moment when you wake up on a Saturday and realize you're dead-

[Former Member]

Why? He had so much to live for. He was just a nobody, yes, but he was our nobody. He always attended our celebratory bonfires and never complained when it was his turn to fetch water from the nearby stream. No more will I dally, drinking hot chocolate and eating s'mores, while justice waits to be served! I will avenge you, normal villager Robert, if it's the last thing I do.

*epic legendary intense massive heroic vengeful dramatic music plays*

[Former Member]

Well @kipp if it isn't you like you're conveying, then it's likely to be RedBassett. I don't believe @dmage would be playing the game like this if he was mafia.

[Former Member]

I'm going with @kipp

Someone is our doctor. Villager or not, if Chani is the doc. Then were all screwed. But ill go through with this.

@kipp

[Former Member]

I don't know what my thoughts are on Nick. I didn't initially suspect him, but the timestamps tell us that he posted a few minutes after Robert was found dead. Also, he has just been going along with everyone else's accusations, never making any deductions himself and being careful to never be the first to accuse someone (and therefore risk being accused himself).

I suspected RedBassett yesterday, but today we found Robert dead and you instantly started accusing me just because I'm active. You would think that RedBassett's inactivity would be a greater reason for suspicion than my willingness to contribute, especially since I have actively tried preventing pointless deaths from the start. But if you were mafia, of course you'd want me lynched over RedBassett, because someone who is really active poses more of a threat to you.

I don't know what I think. I'm suspicious of everyone and, if we don't find the mafia member today and lynch them, I'm pretty sure I'll be the one getting killed tonight because of my suspicion. Following that, I stand to lose the most from today's decision. I'd like to think on it.

[Former Member]

I'm very torn between @kipp & @dmage - someone is taking us villagers for a serious ride here

I'd say my instincts are still with @kipp

I think we need a lynching just to bring us closer to the answer, or someone needs to slip up. 

The more we chat the better

so I encourage you all, lets get talking! That's bound to be uncomfortable for the mafia member

lets have a nice lil' chit chat!

lets pressure this mafia member out of their lil' hidey hole

they'll slip up at some point

[Former Member]

You seriously still suspect me? I would have to be stupid to advise you guys against pointlessly killing each other on the first day, especially since it was clear that I wasn't in any danger of being the one lynched. You and Robert were going at it and Nick sided with Robert just because. If I'd pushed, we could've lynched you, but I wasn't convinced you were mafia and I didn't want to risk losing a villager without some evidence.

[Former Member]

Dec 20, 2014 11:33:36 GMT -8 @kipp said:

I don't know what my thoughts are on Nick. I didn't initially suspect him, but the timestamps tell us that he posted a few minutes after Robert was found dead. Also, he has just been going along with everyone else's accusations, never making any deductions himself and being careful to never be the first to accuse someone (and therefore risk being accused himself).

I suspected RedBassett yesterday, but today we found Robert dead and you instantly started accusing me just because I'm active. You would think that RedBassett's inactivity would be a greater reason for suspicion than my willingness to contribute, especially since I have actively tried preventing pointless deaths from the start. But if you were mafia, of course you'd want me lynched over RedBassett, because someone who is really active poses more of a threat to you.

I don't know what I think. I'm suspicious of everyone and, if we don't find the mafia member today and lynch them, I'm pretty sure I'll be the one getting killed tonight because of my suspicion. Following that, I stand to lose the most from today's decision. I'd like to think on it.

It wasn't because of your activity. It actually has no reason right now. I'm throwing out accusations. I have a feeling I'm dying tonight. I got my affairs in order for a just-in-case. Whomever this Mafia is, is smart. We don't stand a chance.

Red has an alibi. I see him posting on Twitter, being late for a bus and walking home 4 miles in 30 degree weather last night is not exactly posting on here material. I'd turn my headphones up, jam my cold hands deep into my pocket and walk the distance, not post on here! 

So, That leaves me, you and zar up for suspicion, I know I'm not a Mafia. So I really can't accuse myself. 

Like I said whomever the mafia is is really smart! Red could have deliberately posted that to throw us off. But I will be naive and go with it. So, I'm still voting for Chani.

[Former Member]

Interesting @kipp, you are making quite a good point, and it's the sort of defense that doesn't make me suspicious.

After that I'm inclined to go for @dmage...

He was my number 2 in the suspicsion list.

It was a pretty dozy move to take out Robert, and I could see @dmage doing that..

Also he's praising this mafia member saying they're smart.. they're not that smart if they took out Robert when they did..

also if you're complimenting the member, you're distancing yourself as much as possible from actually being one...

So far, that's made my mind up till now.

Nick

[Former Member]

Dec 20, 2014 12:09:28 GMT -8 @zar said:

Interesting @kipp, you are making quite a good point, and it's the sort of defense that doesn't make me suspicious.

After that I'm inclined to go for @dmage...

He was my number 2 in the suspicsion list.

It was a pretty dozy move to take out Robert, and I could see @dmage doing that..

Also he's praising this mafia member saying they're smart.. they're not that smart if they took out Robert when they did..

also if you're complimenting the member, you're distancing yourself as much as possible from actually being one...

So far, that's made my mind up till now.

Nick

I can assure you I am not the Mafia. But any accused person would say that. So, go with it I suppose! But, one of my affairs is before I die, is that I am with child.

[Former Member]

That's a very weird response, that helps confirm it for me too