Mafia Game (After Party)

[Ryan Roos]

Dec 16, 2010 14:11:12 GMT -8 bagheera said:

Dec 16, 2010 11:10:55 GMT -8 aether said:

No, I specifically rejected the idea of popular vote for day 1, so I'd like to remain that much consistent to this point. Only if everyone agrees that they won't change votes, we'll have to look at more options.

The one I think would be easiest won't be in the best interest of the players in terms of gameplay. That's for someone to just bite the bullet and take on the votes to progress the game or end the game, whichever situation it leads to.

What about killing off both Ryan and I if the votes remain consistent?

He asked for someone to take the bullet, not two people. I'm not going to let you take a villager with you.

Edit: Also Bagheera didn't vote. I still vote Bagheera.

[bagheera]

Dec 16, 2010 14:28:15 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Dec 16, 2010 14:11:12 GMT -8 bagheera said:

What about killing off both Ryan and I if the votes remain consistent?

He asked for someone to take the bullet, not two people. I'm not going to let you take a villager with you.

Edit: Also Bagheera didn't vote. I still vote Bagheera.

I did place my final vote already; Ryan, of course.

It's not like I'm all kamikaze here, silly. I'm suggesting a solution that's fair to both sides. What alternative do you propose if the vote doesn't change?

[Ryan Roos]

Dec 16, 2010 14:36:36 GMT -8 bagheera said:

Dec 16, 2010 14:28:15 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

He asked for someone to take the bullet, not two people. I'm not going to let you take a villager with you.

Edit: Also Bagheera didn't vote. I still vote Bagheera.

I did place my final vote already; Ryan, of course.

It's not like I'm all kamikaze here, silly. I'm suggesting a solution that's fair to both sides. What alternative do you propose if the vote doesn't change?

I don't think its fair. We only know 2 mafia and aren't sure about the other two at all. That level of secrecy means the villagers would be one down.

I already proposed popular vote at the end of the day like the wiki says. You're just lucky that Aether is against that for some reason.

Why won't you accept the popular vote and kill yourself?

I vote Baheera still.

[bagheera]

Dec 16, 2010 14:43:41 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Dec 16, 2010 14:36:36 GMT -8 bagheera said:

I did place my final vote already; Ryan, of course.

It's not like I'm all kamikaze here, silly. I'm suggesting a solution that's fair to both sides. What alternative do you propose if the vote doesn't change?

I don't think its fair. We only know 2 mafia and aren't sure about the other two at all. That level of secrecy means the villagers would be one down.

I already proposed popular vote at the end of the day like the wiki says. You're just lucky that Aether is against that for some reason.

Why won't you accept the popular vote and kill yourself?

I vote Baheera still.

It's pretty obvious... because we'll lose the game if we did that.

The best solution for the Mafia is for me to die. The best solution for the villagers is for you to die.

The best compromise is for us both to die, and the remaining villagers will still have half a chance (3 vs 5, 3 vs 4 if a villager dies tonight). If I flat-out die, it's 4 vs 5, 4 vs 4 if a villager dies tonight, so again, the village has an 80% chance of losing... not a chance I'm willing to take.

Of course, you're opposed to this because flat-out killing me will mean you guys pretty much win the game, and I'd rather not do it because I'd like one more night to confirm the fourth Mafia mamber.

You're also opposed to this because both of our roles will be revealed, and the village will be able to kill off the remaining Mafia and thus win the game. But hey, if you were really a villager, you'd worry more about keeping the numbers up so it's possible to win the game, right?

But if it comes down to it, which I'm pretty sure it will, I'm in favour of this because my life doesn't matter as much as saving the village. And if you were truly a villager, you'd support it, too.

[Thesealion]

I think that if Aether thinks we should do it than it is fine with me...

but still not changing my vote

[bagheera]

Yeah, I addressed that remark (about a possible solution) to him -- Ryan butted in to offer his opinion. Still waiting for his feedback on whether this is possible.

[Dumezil]

Can we magically have the before absent village hermit pop up and make the deciding vote?

[bagheera]

Not a half-bad idea, but it'd probably just screw up the game more than eliminating both. After all, in a realistic situation (I can't believe I'm talking about realism and lynching together), if it were a tie, both lynching mobs could drag us both off and lynch us together. xD

[VS Admin]

*hermit pops in* bagheera

[bagheera]

Oh, shush, you. You're only voting for me because I'm not red.

[VS Admin]

No, because I've heard all week from Ryan about how you're mafia.

[bagheera]

Oh, I see... so, shall I recruit people I've been talking to about Ryan being Mafia?

[VS Admin]

There's only one village hermit.

[bagheera]

Well then, we'll just have to recruit the village ghosts. I'm sure they'd be happy to help out.

[Thesealion]

Aether already banned ghosts...she said nothing about hermits...

lol