Mafia Game (After Party)

[Dove]

Final Vote: Ryan

[bagheera]

Dec 16, 2010 15:44:56 GMT -8 Thesealion said:

Aether already banned ghosts...she said nothing about hermits...

lol

Ghosts are more a part of the game than suddenly-appearing hermits. Also, you really think Aether is a girl?

Well, that's everyone who voted for Ryan not changing their vote.

[Ryan Roos]

Dec 16, 2010 15:52:23 GMT -8 Dove said:

Final Vote: Ryan

Little by little I start to wonder if you might be mafia. You messaged me and asked for trust. I treated you with respect and tried to answer all your questions. I'm glad I didn't tell you who the real detective is.

It also explains why you're in Bagheera's video so much.

You took what was a popular vote and made it a stalemate.

Just a thought for all the other villagers in case I die.

[Dove]

Dec 16, 2010 15:57:32 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Dec 16, 2010 15:52:23 GMT -8 Dove said:

Final Vote: Ryan

Little by little I start to wonder if you might be mafia. You messaged me and asked for trust. I treated you with respect and tried to answer all your questions. I'm glad I didn't tell you who the real detective is.

It also explains why you're in Bagheera's video so much.

You took what was a popular vote and made it a stalemate.

Just a thought for all the other villagers in case I die.

I shouldn't have to explain myself to you, but if you are wondering why I was in her video so much (creeper much?) it was because I was asking her why she should stay alive, just as I asked you. I asked for honesty and trust, just as I asked you. She gave me her thoughts and opinions, just as you did. She proved to me you were mafia. You didn't.

[Ryan Roos]

Dove

Ok just for the record, after that comment. Now I think you are mafia. I answered every question you had.

And you even sent me this.

Okay thanks. I really don't believe Bagheera. She's too flip-floppy for me. She says one thing one second, another thing the next.

And while you weren't pushy about learning who the real detective is you did want to know. You wanted re-assurance. I even told you I couldn't tell you since I didn't know if you were mafia or not.

That quote was one of the last things you said to me and then when there was a popular vote you still went the other way.

Pay attention other villagers!

[Dove]

See guys, look now. Ryan's trying to pin this all on me.

I can honestly say I am not mafia. I am positive Bagheera is detective, and the nurse has shared with me who he is, but OH NOO I'M NOT GOING TO SHARE WITH ANYONE! Big deal. I'm a villager, you're mafia. Bottom line.

And yes, I wanted to know who you really thought was detective. You wouldn't share because they don't exsist, it's just a ploy that you mafia have.

[Ryan Roos]

Dec 16, 2010 16:11:36 GMT -8 Dove said:

See guys, look now. Ryan's trying to pin this all on me.

I can honestly say I am not mafia. I am positive Bagheera is detective, and the nurse has shared with me who he is, but OH NOO I'M NOT GOING TO SHARE WITH ANYONE! Big deal. I'm a villager, you're mafia. Bottom line.

And yes, I wanted to know who you really thought was detective. You wouldn't share because they don't exsist, it's just a ploy that you mafia have.

I shared with iCraft who it was after iCraft proved that he was a villager. I really believed you were a villager. Sincerely. Now suddenly you are all about me being mafia. I feel that you changed too dramatically once I wouldn't tell you the real detective. That is the only reason I think you are either working with Bagheera as mafia, or like Phaelyn you have fallen for her trap. Good luck if it's the latter.

[Dove]

Dec 16, 2010 16:19:53 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Dec 16, 2010 16:11:36 GMT -8 Dove said:

See guys, look now. Ryan's trying to pin this all on me.

I can honestly say I am not mafia. I am positive Bagheera is detective, and the nurse has shared with me who he is, but OH NOO I'M NOT GOING TO SHARE WITH ANYONE! Big deal. I'm a villager, you're mafia. Bottom line.

And yes, I wanted to know who you really thought was detective. You wouldn't share because they don't exsist, it's just a ploy that you mafia have.

I shared with iCraft who it was after iCraft proved that he was a villager. I really believed you were a villager. Sincerely. Now suddenly you are all about me being mafia. I feel that you changed too dramatically once I wouldn't tell you the real detective. That is the only reason I think you are either working with Bagheera as mafia, or like Phaelyn you have fallen for her trap. Good luck if it's the latter.

Yeah, that's because I am a villager. And oh Ryan. You would know this ploy so well, as you are doing it every time you type a post. It's called Poker Face. I knew all along you were mafia, and hey, you ever think as to why you thought I was a villager??? Maybe because I am!

And yes, I was quiet throughout this entire game, only conversing through PMs, which you know quite well already. I decided to stick up for Bagheera, because she has proven to me she isn't mafia.

Okay, and tell me this. We ALL agree Jetta is mafia. Why hasn't she changed her vote yet to kill you off? Hmm... maybe because you're mafia too. PLEASE EXPLAIN!

[Mr. Spartan]

Dec 16, 2010 16:19:53 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Dec 16, 2010 16:11:36 GMT -8 Dove said:

See guys, look now. Ryan's trying to pin this all on me.

I can honestly say I am not mafia. I am positive Bagheera is detective, and the nurse has shared with me who he is, but OH NOO I'M NOT GOING TO SHARE WITH ANYONE! Big deal. I'm a villager, you're mafia. Bottom line.

And yes, I wanted to know who you really thought was detective. You wouldn't share because they don't exsist, it's just a ploy that you mafia have.

I shared with iCraft who it was after iCraft proved that he was a villager. I really believed you were a villager. Sincerely. Now suddenly you are all about me being mafia. I feel that you changed too dramatically once I wouldn't tell you the real detective. That is the only reason I think you are either working with Bagheera as mafia, or like Phaelyn you have fallen for her trap. Good luck if it's the latter.

It's a pretty good trap then. i doubt it really is though ;D

[Ryan Roos]

Honestly I don't know about Jetta, maybe Jetta can explain. I didn't even notice that until you said it.

I have no freaking clue. Ask Bagheera or Jetta why.

[Dove]

Just as a note to all:

I truly believe Bagheera is a villager/detective. If she isn't, then I've truly screwed up in listening to her and accusing everyone as mafia.

[bagheera]

Here's who Ryan has thought was Mafia:

Dec 13, 2010 8:17:16 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Phaelyn is suspect by way of her actions. She is totally casting votes out front of everyone and then a small pose of people join her.

Dec 13, 2010 9:25:29 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Now I know that both Phaelyn and bagheera are mafia. 2/4 discovered IMO.

Dec 13, 2010 11:23:57 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

I think Jetta could be mafia!

Dec 13, 2010 14:08:20 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Is Syko Nachxmas your fourth? Sent to confuse us as the vote draws to a close?

Dec 16, 2010 16:06:13 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Dove

Now I think you are mafia.

Now who's naming five Mafia members?

Also, I wonder why Jetta is still voting for me -- and miraculously switched her vote from Ryan to me at just before clinch time last night -- when Ryan has been just as persistent in condemning her. Given that she's certainly Mafia, why protect Ryan? Hmmm, bears thinking about.

[Ryan Roos]

I retracted Syko after confirming he was a villager.

And I've only ever claimed to know for sure that you and Jetta were mafia (and even Jetta is only 98%) since you are the only one the detective confirmed.

Once again pot calling the kettle black. Just sitting around waiting for me to name a fifth so you could copy my logic again. Un-original.

Edit : I also like that all your quotes were from Monday, the first day I started playing. Ha! Oh sorry that's another fact you like to overlook for me being mafia, I wasn't even playing for the first 2 real world days, when 2 villagers were killed by the mafia.

[Ara (Crow)]

I am a lone villiager who has no idea what is going on anymore...

[bagheera]

Dec 16, 2010 16:43:32 GMT -8 Ryan Roos said:

Oh sorry that's another fact you like to overlook for me being mafia, I wasn't even playing for the first 2 real world days, when 2 villagers were killed by the mafia.

Sorry, but I don't have any reason to believe you. You were online from home last night, you could very easily have been online from home over the weekend. Plus, we don't know how the Mafia vote works... do illuminate us, since you're so knowledgeable.

This is really ticking me off. I do hope that Nightwalker or iCraft are in PM communication with Dove, Mr. Spartan, Crow, or Thumper, all of whom are clearly villagers. I also hope the latter are threatening to beat about the head whoever causes them to lose the game.

I'm also waiting for why Jetta is protecting you, Ryan.

Oh, and one more thing: why exactly are you so opposed to us both being voted out? Because I've already said I'm willing to do it, and explained why it's the best thing for the village.