GT Mafia: Round 2 ((Post-Game))

[Former Member]

Oh what we've started? HAI THUR YOKELS

where's my shandehhhayyyeee

[Phaelyn]

Dec 29, 2010 6:07:23 GMT -8 @zar said:

Oh what we've started? HAI THUR YOKELS

where's my shandehhhayyyeee

yes, we started about 2 days and ten pages ago. xD

[Former Member]

Dec 29, 2010 6:12:34 GMT -8 Phaelyn said:

Dec 29, 2010 6:07:23 GMT -8 @zar said:

Oh what we've started? HAI THUR YOKELS

where's my shandehhhayyyeee

yes, we started about 2 days and ten pages ago. xD

I knoooo', 'twas surprised! , so we're just waiting for death now haha

[bagheera]

Okay, here we are...

Crow: Nightwalker
woop: Shiraz
Dominick: Ricky
Shiraz: TheLostStocking

Pats Freak 101: Crow
Patrick Clinger: Crow
Ryan: Crow
Ricky: Crow

Nightwalker: Ryan
Alex Zechiel: Ryan
**hp: Ryan
Syko: Ryan
TheLostStocking: Ryan

No need to rush, guys, as we've still got just over 24 hours to decide, and a lot happens in a day in this game.

[Ara (Crow)]

Dec 29, 2010 6:07:23 GMT -8 @zar said:

Oh what we've started? HAI THUR YOKELS

where's my shandehhhayyyeee

Pssh, I forgot about this until the 7th page.

Also, switch my vote to Ryan.

[Former Member]

So we're voting to kill Ryan?

[Ace Trainer Dom]

Maybe I'm alone in this, but it doesn't seen as if ryan is acting like he was last time, therefore I'm not entirely sure he is mafia. Now the people I'm suspicious of are shiraz and theloststocking. They are both arguing too much in this thread over two people with no conclusive evidence . In addition, theloststocking is refusing to go with the majority to ensure we lynch somebody. While lynching a villager may not sound ideal, there is no getting around it the first few rounds, and when a villager is lynched the detective, whomever they may be, can question the narrator about the person(s) who introduced that person and fought most to get them lynched, as mafia are not going to fight to lynch one of their own. As a villager, I am willing to go with the majority each day as long as it means we make progress, even if that means I get lynched, for at each lynching the truth is revealed, and you will find those of us who were loyal to the village, and hopefully the remaining villagers and the detective will be able to use the previous opinions of the now lynched villagers to the advantage of the remainder of the village.

now is that to say that I think shiraz or loststocking are mafia? I'm not sure, they just aren't acting with the best interests of the village in mind, and I Don't think we should blindly follow their arguments without taking a second look first.

having said that, I'll retract my vote for ricky seeing as I'm the only remaining villager voting to lynch him, and for now I will wait to see where the majority goes.

[Phaelyn]

Dec 29, 2010 7:12:40 GMT -8 Ace Trainer Dom said:

Maybe I'm alone in this, but it doesn't seen as if ryan is acting like he was last time, therefore I'm not entirely sure he is mafia.

Not alone, I've said that a few times.

Like I said, I still have no vote. No idea who's who here XD

[Thesealion]

Ok here is what i think of this.

TheLostStocking: Don't really see any good proof to vote for him. Will watch in a later round though.

Shiraz: Seems to be voting for someone random to try to split up the votes. This would be a good strategy for the mafia.

Ryan: Looks suspicious but after last game he isn't as loud trying to defend himself. He hasn't said anything so far that is stretching what a villager would say.

Ricky: Looks REALLY suspicious...what he says just doesn't sound true. It sounds like he is trying to get us to believe something.

Phaelyn: Doesn't seem to want to vote. Could mean she is also trying to confuse us or she could be confused herself...

I am Retracting my vote

[Phaelyn]

Phaelyn wants to vote, she just doesn't feel the need to throw out votes at random. If it makes you feel any better, I'm voting Ricky for now, though I may retract and change if any better evidence comes along.

[Thesealion]

I am leaning to Ricky too...

[Former Member]

I remove my vote for now. I'm not trying a no lynch, just trying to think it through then decide afterwards.

[Ryan Roos]

I know that the detective has been working with a couple of other villagers, or at least another claimed villager told me that.

I sincerely ask that you DO NOT kill me today. I DO ask that the detective check me tonight above everyone else. CHECK ME!!!

The village needs my fight. If I'm quiet its because I'm trying to watch and see who's doing what. I have no solid leads yet. Anyone from the last game should know how hard I fought for the villagers (as mafia). Imagine now how hard I'll fight that I'm actually a villager this time.

I'm telling you now, killing me is a really bad idea.

Edit : If anyone shows me a better reason than the one I am voting for Crow I will change my vote. But Pat's logic is currently the only argument I've heard and Crow is the non-me-popular-vote right now.

[Thesealion]

Ryan one of the admins is Mafia. I am almost sure of it. You making this pact with Ricky makes it hard for everyone since we think that one of you two is Mafia. Do you agree that one of the admins is mafia? Who do you think it is?

[Phaelyn]

I do agree that at least one of them is mafia. However, Ryan really does seem innocent to me. Look, even when he's threatened, we didn't get long posts accusing everyone else -- he merely stated his position. I think we should at least give him another day. Hopefully the detective will investigate him tonight.


Truthfully, I think Ricky's been acting the most suspiciously...for now, my vote's still on him, but I will retract if needed.